Pool heater recommendation

Natural gas, propane, or electric heat pump?

400K BTU natural gas heater from Raypak.
 
Pentair Mastertemp has a smaller cube form factor that fits into my area better. To achieve this it has a forced draft blower which makes it more complicated and costly to repair. Blower on MasterTemp is noisy but my equipment pad is away from the pool area.

Raypak has a natural draft and is a taller unit with exhaust out of the top instead of the side from the MasterTemp.

They are both fine units.
 
Merged several threads. TFP Mod.
Hello!! I have a 20x40 pool with a deep end and diving board. How many gallons of water do I have? I would like to get a pool heater. How many BTUs do you think I should be getting? Thanks all!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
20x40' pool with average depth of 5' is 30,000 gallons. Figure yours is 30,000+ gallons.

You need a 400K BTU heater which will heat your pool a bit over1 degree an hour.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.