Re-plumb to improve flow rate?

[bjohannes]

I've never been thrilled with the plumbing job that my pool builder did in 2017. The equipment pad is about 6.5' above the water line, so the pump (SP23520VSP) has its work cut out for it. I find myself having to run the pump at 90% or more to keep the heater flow sensor happy. When the filter (DE4820) gets even a bit dirty, even 100% pump speed may not be enough to maintain the minimum flow rate for heating.

I've noticed that I could reconfigure the equipment layout and eliminate four 90 degree bends simply by rotating the filter 90 degrees and having the lines go straight into the multiport valve. I could probably also do away with the two 90s that are just upstream of the heater. Would doing so improve my flow rate significantly? Is there any reason not to make these changes?

 

[Jimrahbe]

B,

I doubt that you would even be able to tell any difference between what you have now and your proposed setup..

Something is not right, but I doubt that a few 90's are your issue..

What HP is your pump?

Let's see if we can get one of our flow guys to chime in...

Thanks,

Jim R.

 

[bjohannes]

Thanks Jim. It's 1.65 THP

Home - CA

Hayward offers environmentally responsible, cutting-edge pool and spa equipment for residential and commercial, in-ground and above-ground pools.

www.hayward-pool.ca

 

[IUsedToSail]

His plumbing appears to neck down from 2" to a 1.5" section right before it splits for the returns.... it looks like there is a reducing fitting immediately after what looks like a SWG cell. That has got to be restricting the flow.

 

[Jimrahbe]

His plumbing appears to neck down from 2" to a 1.5" section right before it splits for the returns.... it looks like there is a reducing fitting immediately after what looks like a SWG cell. That has got to be restricting the flow.

I,

It appears to me all his "pool" plumbing is 1.5" except a few things at the pad.. If that is true, it won't make much difference

Jim R.

 

[Jimrahbe]

B,

Let's see if we can get one of our flow guys to chime in on what might help solve your problem...

Calling @JamesW

Thanks,

Jim R.

 

[JamesW]

What is the filter pressure at full speed?

Is the pump wired to 115 or 230 volts?

If you can get a vacuum reading that would be helpful.

If you added a flow meter, that would help diagnose the issue.

If you can convert the filter pressure and vacuum pressure to feet of head, you can see what the expected flow rate is supposed to be at the below speeds.

For example, if the vacuum plus filter pressure is 20 psi, the total head is about 46.2 feet.

If we look at 46.2 feet of head and 115 volts, the flow is expected to be about 37 gpm.

If the pump is receiving 115 volts, the top speed is reduced to limit the maximum amps as shown in the black dotted line.

How far is the pump from the pool?

 

[JamesW]

The equipment pad is about 6.5' above the water line, so the pump (SP23520VSP) has its work cut out for it. I find myself having to run the pump at 90% or more to keep the heater flow sensor happy.

Part of the problem is that the heater does not have a flow switch, it has a pressure switch.

Because the heater sits so far above the water, the pressure in the heater is significantly reduced and the flow has to be much higher than normal to activate the pressure switch.

I would switch to a flow switch instead of a pressure switch.

Pool & Spa | Fluid Flow and Liquid Level Switches | Harwil - Oxnard, CA

HomePool & SpaPool & SpaHarwil Flow Switches are used by almost all of the major pool equipment and spa manufacturers in the world. Harwil Flow Switches are a critical part of the new generation of salt water chlorine generators which are used to replace adding chlorine to a swimming pool. The...

harwil.com

 

[bjohannes]

His plumbing appears to neck down from 2" to a 1.5" section right before it splits for the returns.... it looks like there is a reducing fitting immediately after what looks like a SWG cell. That has got to be restricting the flow.

Good catch, I think you're right. I'll check in the morning, but I'm pretty sure all of the other plumbing is 2" (except the main drain and the returns).

 

[DeanP66]

So, your pool builder built the pad like this from scratch in 2017? I can't believe he used all that flex pvc instead of hard pipe? Maybe it was just a retrofit??

 

[bjohannes]

What is the filter pressure at full speed?

Is the pump wired to 115 or 230 volts?

If you can get a vacuum reading that would be helpful.

If you added a flow meter, that would help diagnose the issue.

If you can convert the filter pressure and vacuum pressure to feet of head, you can see what the expected flow rate is supposed to be at the below speeds.

For example, if the vacuum plus filter pressure is 20 psi, the total head is about 46.2 feet.

If we look at 46.2 feet of head and 115 volts, the flow is expected to be about 37 gpm.

If the pump is receiving 115 volts, the top speed is reduced to limit the maximum amps as shown in the black dotted line.

How far is the pump from the pool?
View attachment 337547

Pretty sure it's wired for 230 volts. I just completely disassembled the DE filter, fully cleaned and soaked the grids (dishwasher detergent then 10% muriatic acid) then reassembled and added fresh DE. Filter pressure now reads 8PSI at 100% pump speed.

Part of the problem is that the heater does not have a flow switch, it has a pressure switch.

Because the heater sits so far above the water, the pressure in the heater is significantly reduced and the flow has to be much higher than normal to activate the pressure switch.

I would switch to a flow switch instead of a pressure switch.

Pool & Spa | Fluid Flow and Liquid Level Switches | Harwil - Oxnard, CA

HomePool & SpaPool & SpaHarwil Flow Switches are used by almost all of the major pool equipment and spa manufacturers in the world. Harwil Flow Switches are a critical part of the new generation of salt water chlorine generators which are used to replace adding chlorine to a swimming pool. The...

harwil.com

Can you swap the pressure switch for a flow switch in a Hayward NG heater?

 

[bjohannes]

So, your pool builder built the pad like this from scratch in 2017? I can't believe he used all that flex pvc instead of hard pipe? Maybe it was just a retrofit??

Yup, this was from scratch. I feel like he just used whatever parts he had at the time. The check valve was added later on (but probably should have gone ahead of the pump somehow).

 

[bjohannes]

His plumbing appears to neck down from 2" to a 1.5" section right before it splits for the returns.... it looks like there is a reducing fitting immediately after what looks like a SWG cell. That has got to be restricting the flow.

Would I just replace the part after the SWG with a 2" section and 2" tee, and use a 2" to 1.5" adapter on the returns?

 

[JamesW]

You can install a flow switch in the line going to the heater and connect it to the wires that would normally go to the pressure switch.

Below, you can see the SWG salt cell flow switch (marked F) and where to install a new flow switch (Also marked F).

The flow switch goes in a T with a 1/2” npt female thread like the one for the SWG salt system.

Install flow switch.

Remove wires from pressure switch.

Connect wires from flow switch to wires that were on the pressure switch.

 

[JamesW]

The flow switch need to be set to trigger at about 10 gpm per 100,000 btu/hr of heater.

A 200,000 btu/hr needs 20 gpm.
a 400,000 btu/hr heater needs 40 gpm etc.

Contact Harwil for the right flow switch that will fit in the 2" T with a 1/2" female thread.

The Aquarite SWG flow switch triggers at about 15 to 20 gpm, so it won't be a good choice for a bigger heater like a 400,000 btu/hr.

 

[DeanP66]

Yup, this was from scratch. I feel like he just used whatever parts he had at the time. The check valve was added later on (but probably should have gone ahead of the pump somehow).

I can see why you weren't thrilled. There's no excuse for a professional to do a plumbing job like that, especially considering it was a new build. To put flex pvc plus a hose clamp in front of the pump like that boggles my mind. Why would he not just run a longer piece of straight hard pipe right into the the coupler?

It looks like he used all flex pvc underground, which is not the way to go. He could have at least come out of the ground perpendicular and made it look professional. That flex piece coming out of the 90 elbow of the pump discharge is gonna fail eventually with all the downward weight from being filled with water. I'd replace that sooner rather than later.

 

[JamesW]

Each heater maker makes a flow switch for their heaters. Hayward, Raypak, Pentair etc.

Some come with different paddles that allow you to adjust the trigger flow by changing the paddle.

Raypak Flow Switch Kit - 007142F - INYOPools.com

Flow Switch Kit - 007142F

www.inyopools.com

Heaters Parts | Heaters | Parts & Accessories | Commercial - Hayward Pool Products

Hayward commercial pool products are supported by a full range of replacement parts and accessories for heaters. Universal H-Series gas heaters combine industry-leading hydraulics,and energy efficiency and reliability, with low-NOx emissions.

www.hayward-pool.com

 

[JamesW]

 

[JamesW]

UHXFSW1930 - H-Series H150-H500 Flow Switch Kit - Hayward

This is a Hayward Flow Switch Kit for the H-Series Low NOx pool heaters, models H150 to H500.

www.poolweb.com

Kit-Flow Switch

Kit-Flow Switch

pstpoolsupplies.com

 

[JamesW]

114400 - McDonnell & Miller 114400 - FS4-3, 1" General Purpose Flow Switch - Paddle Style

McDonnell & Miller 114400 - FS4-3, 1" General Purpose Flow Switch - Paddle Style - Universal design serves the widest variety of applications. For starting or stopping electrically operated equipment such as signal lights, alarms, motors, automatic burners, metering devices and others.<br><br>...

www.supplyhouse.com

McDonnell & Miller Series FS4-3 General Purpose Liquid Flow Switches | Xylem US

mcdonnellmiller.com