High salt with Leslie’s normal salt with me

poolmom21

Gold Supporter
Jul 27, 2021
186
Indio, CA
Pool Size
25000
Surface
Plaster
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
SWG Type
Hayward Aqua Rite (T-15)
Hi retested salt levels at home and at Leslie’s. Leslie’s is 3700 and I’m at 3200 using the test kit

What do I do?
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    423.1 KB · Views: 5
mom,

What salt test kit are you using at home?? If a Taylor kit, and using a speed-stir, then I'd trust your own readings..

There is a 50/50 chance that Leslie's is wrong, no matter what chemicals they are testing... :mrgreen:

I would also think that your SWCG will work just fine at 3200...

Thanks,

Jim R.
 
You have 2 people in your relationship. The Test kit and the cell. Leslie's is nothing but a homewrecker.

What does the cell say ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: oledan
mom,

What salt test kit are you using at home?? If a Taylor kit, and using a speed-stir, then I'd trust your own readings..

There is a 50/50 chance that Leslie's is wrong, no matter what chemicals they are testing... :mrgreen:

I would also think that your SWCG will work just fine at 3200...

Thanks,

Jim R.
Yes using TFP kit and reagents and salt speed stir.
Thank you
 
Whoa whoa whoa. How did it fail ? Low or high salt ? It may be something silly or something medium bad but not terrible, like a sensor
I kept getting a troubleshoot light on the box. I took the cell to Leslie’s since it was purchased 1 year or so ago and they checked it and said it wasn’t working so need to get it replaced under warranty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude
Ok. You can spend *their* money all day everyday if they're willing to replace it. Before you ever spend your own, come check first. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: poolmom21

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
I kept getting a troubleshoot light on the box. I took the cell to Leslie’s since it was purchased 1 year or so ago and they checked it and said it wasn’t working so need to get it replaced

Ok. You can spend *their* money all day everyday if they're willing to replace it. Before you ever spend your own, come check first. :)
Let me ask you do I go and add cya or do I wait until I get the salt cell replaced? I do have liquid chlorine to keep it a cya/fc ratio levels. Please advice.
 
Add 10 to get to 30 CYA. Then Overnight Chlorine Loss Test. (Can be done while CYA is soaking or even before if you dont have leftover CYA) Each 10 CYA raises slam FC by +4. You'd rather slam at 12 FC than 28 FC (70 CYA) and nows the time to prove it won't be needed.
 
Add 10 to get to 30 CYA. Then Overnight Chlorine Loss Test. (Can be done while CYA is soaking or even before if you dont have leftover CYA) Each 10 CYA raises slam FC by +4. You'd rather slam at 12 FC than 28 FC (70 CYA) and nows the time to prove it won't be needed.
Sorry can you re explain?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude
You will want 70 CYA for the SWG.

Never raise CYA significantly without passing the OCLT, even with clear water. Higher CYA slams eat through chlorine which stinks for you and your wallet.

Slam needs 30 CYA min so you can add 10 CYA to the existing 20 per your poolmath logs either way. This is independent of needing the OCLT if you dont have CYA on hand.

If you pass the OCLT you can add in stages of CYA so you are ready to go with 70 CYA when the new cell arrives.

Click/read the article (Overnight Chlorine Loss Test)
for more details, or keep asking. :)
 
You will want 70 CYA for the SWG.

Never raise CYA significantly without passing the OCLT, even with clear water. Higher CYA slams eat through chlorine which stinks for you and your wallet.

Slam needs 30 CYA min so you can add 10 CYA to the existing 20 per your poolmath logs. This is independent of needing the OCLT if you dont have CYA on hand.

If you pass the OCLT you can add in stages of CYA so you are ready to go with 70 CYA when the new cell arrives.

Click/read the article (Overnight Chlorine Loss Test)
for more details, or keep asking. :)
Ok so I I fail the OCLT then I do slam until I pass using the cya of 30/fc ratio correct?
If I pass, add the rest of cya now or wait until I get the new salt cell?
 
Ok so I I fail the OCLT then I do slam until I pass using the cya of 30/fc ratio correct?
Yes. (y) (assuming you add 10 CYA)
If I pass, add the rest of cya now or wait until I get the new salt cell?
Yes. (y) I'd prefer to have less time without a SWG, but no harm comes in waiting. You do want the 30 CYA either way though.
 
Yes. (y) (assuming you add 10 CYA)

Yes. (y) I'd prefer to have less time without a SWG, but no harm comes in waiting. You do want the 30 CYA either way though.
So I tested this morning but the pool was already running for maybe 45-50 min but the fc went from 4.5 to 5.5, tomorrow I will try to get up by 5 am before the pool runs and will do the overnight chorine test again. But it seems I don’t have contaminants in the pool as of now.

So basically replace the salt cell then add the rest of the cya correct?
 
but the fc went from 4.5 to 5.5,
Was the old SWG off ? Or is this a typo?
I will try to get up by 5 am before the pool runs and will do the overnight chorine test again
Shut the cell off or unplug it. Get a baseline test after dark. Then get the other test in the morning. You dont have to run the pump overnight, but if you do, it'll save some sleep because you can just roll out of bed and test.
So basically replace the salt cell then add the rest of the cya correct?
Yup. Aim a little low just in case and creep up the last bit.
 
Was the old SWG off ? Or is this a typo?

Shut the cell off or unplug it. Get a baseline test after dark. Then get the other test in the morning. You dont have to run the pump overnight, but if you do, it'll save some sleep because you can just roll out of bed and test.

Yup. Aim a little low just in case and creep up the last bit.
So I connected the current swg while I wait to get the new one delivered then do the exchange because we are using the pool this weekend and wanted to run the pool system. So came home and hooked it back on. I took the reading last night one hour after I added 1 gallon of the cya. Turned off the system. The system is set to turn on around 6 am. I took this mornings test to compare at 7 ish.
 
The system is set to turn on around 6 am. I took this mornings test to compare at 7 ish.
Ok. Whoops. If any FC is added you won't see a loss (if its there).

Verify its off for tonight's test then again that its not turned on yet when you get the morning test.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support