Sand filter size. Over 24 inches?

Testinglife

Member
Aug 24, 2022
18
Canada
Hello,

I have been doing some reading here and it seems when it comes to sand filters, bigger is better, and results in less frequent backwashing. There doesn't seem to be any down size other than it requires more space and obviously costs more. I have seen 30 inch recommend or even bigger.

When talking to a few different pool stores where I live they basically have all told me that 24 is the golden standard and that only commercial pools need a 27, 30, or 36. Most of them don't even stock bigger than 24 and special order them in.

I would love to hear people's opinions. I don't like backwash because I have a hundred foot blue pool hose that I have to neatly unwrap and wrap up each time and it takes a while to set and then backwash. If I have ti replace the sand filter anyways I would love to do it right and not change it down the road.

This isn't really about if I should change my filter or not but the reason is it's spitting sand out into the pool, it started leaking from the top header thing (don't know the name of things), and it's at least 20 years old so probably time for an upgrade anyways.

Also,If you have brand and model recommendations I am all ears. I have a 18k gallon pool. Chlorine, not swg, not sure the HP of motor but can check if its important.
 
Thanks I re read this just now and I believe this is what started me down the bigger is better for sand filters path. I definitely have the pad space for it, and I noted this paragraph here that says, "

Pool Filter Types​

  • Sand filters are the simplest. Most pools should use a minimum of a 24” sand filter with pools greater than 25,000 gallons or in high debris areas using a 30” filter. Sand filters use lots of water to clean them. Therefore you should select a large sand filter that will need less frequent backwashing, and thus use less water."
Minimum of 24 for over 25,000 gallons. Does that mean then for an 18,000 gallon pool that 24 is good? Or do I still stick to the biggest possible when possible?

I was just shocked to see that 4 pool stores and installers all recommend 24 (and one recommended 22). I was expected to be welcomed when I asked for 30 and they basically all said not to do it as it was for commercial pools.
 
I was just shocked to see that 4 pool stores and installers all recommend 24 (and one recommended 22). I was expected to be welcomed when I asked for 30 and they basically all said not to do it as it was for commercial pools.
I am PoolStored...ask me why...

Sincerely,
PoolStored.
 
I should also add that unfortunately my back yard is very very high debris due to a few awful trees along my fence on the neighbour's side. They basically dropped pedals, leaves, seeds every day all summer and then drop never ending small branches as well, all falling in the pool. I work from home and probably skim my pool about 5 times a day to keep up. Currently in early summer I am filling up a large garbage can full of debris a week just from skimming with a net.
 
Up to you. Skimmer nets (hairnets over the skimmer baskets) really reduces debris load.

What pump do you have? You need enough pump power to backwash a big sand filter.
 
Haha I would love to know why. I have a feeling I should put on my earmuffs when talking to pool stores.
Oh the woes...They sold me a $1000 uv system. UV just consumes FC, and is really only necessary for an indoor pool that doesn't get UV. Further, they made different recommendation on pool potions to add, even with the same chemical test results. Get a good test kit, trust it and trust TFP. Proof...Link-->How Clear is TFP Clear?
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Information from @JamesW
The maximum flow rate for a sand filter should be about 15 gpm per square foot.
Backwash should be 15 gpm per square foot.
There is no minimum flow rate.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.