Salt and steel

Ourad

Silver Supporter
Jun 25, 2019
84
Tulsa, OK
Pool Size
22000
Surface
Plaster
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
SWG Type
Pentair Intellichlor IC-60
Hi there, so I am in the process of finalizing our spa design, and have been talking spillovers with our builder. We are going to have a fairly wide, 5-6 ft spillover, which sort of reduces our options to a stone slab, or a copper/steel spillover. Talking with the copper/steel company, I mentioned I was going to have a salt pool, based on all the information I have gained here. They strongly insisted that a stainless steel spillover would get "chewed up" by the salt, and even if i powder coated it, the salts would chew up the powder coating. They said copper would perform better, but still might see some damage down the line. I'm not sure patina'd copper would go with the rest of the tile/coping selection, so I was leaning steel. I would rather not do tile since I prefer an actual spillover rather than trickling down the tile wall.

Is salt truly the great destroyer of steel, or is this outdated information. The consensus from other posts i have read here seems to be general chemistry is usually the issue, mainly pH, but I just wanted to confirm before I forged ahead.

On a related but separate note, should I be pushing to have a sacrificial anode installed? Is this something that should be standard on any salt pool?
 
O,

I doubt saltwater would eat powered coated steal and faster then regular pool water would.. I would expect that over time, the powered coating would breakdown and need to be recoated.

The Golden gate bridge is a good example.. Lives in a real saltwater environment and needs to be continuously repainted.

I'd use stainless steel or tile.. Stainless steel comes in many different types and they don't all resist rust the same way..

Thanks,

Jim R.
 
You don't want to use copper on the spillway that can leach copper into the water.


A sacrificial anode is only needed if you have metals around your pool that you need to protect. Normal pool equipment have nothing that needs protection.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mdragger88
Thanks guys. That makes sense about the copper. I guess most people just don't care (or know) since copper scuppers seem to be everywhere I look. I would be fine with the tile and having it just sheet down the tile wall, but my wife is set on a glass tile and we have been told that isn't a great idea with the occasional freeze/thaws we get around here. Sounds like a high quality stainless steel might be the way to go.
 
You want 316L grade stainless steel. 316 is also good enough but 316L is the best. It's used in pool and marine environments all the time.

304 stainless will rust eventually in salt water, so make sure it's 316. copper is no good. You can get "marine bronze" alloys as well but pure copper will oxidise very quickly, in the same way that pure iron would rust very quickly.

also, talk to a different copper/steel company. they're idiots. if a steel specialist doesn't know about 316... wow. and recommending copper? double wow.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.