Good possibility. I had a skimmer line get plugged and when both main drain and skimmer open - all worked. When just main drain open for suction it also worked. However when just skimmer line open for suction then it would not pull water to pump. But you are having issues with both skimmer and main drain drawing suction as I understand it. You can try to surge your skimmer line by rotating your valve full open to full close while pumpe is running with your hose in it. I purchased a hose from Amazon that connected to my power washer and I pushed that down the skimmer line as far as I could with the power washer. If finally pushed enough debris close to my pump that it then broke up and came out.
I purchased this at amazon
Thanks. I tried something similar with air today and the mystery continues. I hooked up my large air compressor to a large conical rubber plug with the air nozzle through the center of the plug, stuck it in the skimmer and blew the skimmer line. Seems like not too much debris was in there and I had a lot of psi going through there. Blew the loosened lid off the pump. So i thought maybe it could drawing air from one of the old pvc connections, so I replaced all of the 1 1/2 pvc piping from the drain and skimmer lines going to the pump, plus the pump fittings.
So now, if I have someone hold the plug in the skimmer line and I fill the line and pump with the garden hose, it'll prime up and run on recirculate. BUT 3 things:
1. If I turn off the pump, it's the same issue when I turn back on. It just won't prime, won't suck water into the basket from the skimmer line (drain line closed)
2. I tried just slightly opening the drain valve while pump was running on skimmer only and the pump lost prime and wouldn't prime up again..even after closing the drain valve immediately. Keep in mind that when I cut off the old shut off valve on drain line, you could see that the drain line was full of water.
3. I'm getting air bubbles out of the returns even after running it for an hour to purge the line, also the pump basket isn't quite full of water to the top of the cover while running. Suction at skimmer is fine.
So I have to plug the skimmer with drain closed, fill pump until overflow, start pump and have someone immediately remove the skimmer plug for it to run. If I open the drain line at all, it loses prime. If I turn pump off, I have to repeat the process to get it started.
I'm just stumped with this one.