New EVO 614i Robot Pool Cleaner Review

Hi swolk,
I just bought EVO 614iq after my active 30i died. I bought from Marina because of all the good mentions about them on this site. However if you read through this thread you have to pay to send it back to Marina for warrantee work if needed.

I have only had it for about a week and I have fine filter as well as standard filter. In my opinion either my pool is a lot cleaner this year (which I doubt) or the pleated filters do much better. If you look back in this thread I believe Jim posted pic of fine mud the fine filter picked up after her got the fine filter and it was a bunch of fine mud or silt. This is what I would get many times with the Active 30 filter, but I am personally not getting it with the fine filter, but the water looks ok.

The Evo has an app to set a daily schedule, which I have not set up yet because I am lazy and do not want to give out all the personal info they require to start it, so I have been pushing the buttons like I did with the Active 30i.

The pro's so far of this unit over the Active 20 (which was what I was considering to buy) is that the cord is thicker and stiffer and the swivel is much better than A20. While this cord can twist it is much less and much much easier to get untwisted. I have run the unit 3 cycles without untwisting (after 3 cycles I took it out to swim not because the line was twisted). the unit is also stronger on suction and has climbed my stairs and tried to clean my steps but it does not do much but at least it returns to the pool and does not flip on its back the way my A30i did if it attempted to climb the steps, which meant someone had to upright it manually so it could run again. It also does not hang up on the bottom drain which A30i did almost all the time, even with bottom drain turned off. I bought a ramp cover to solve the problem but it just sat on top of the drain cover unattached and frequently would get pushed off and it was a pain to reset it. I think Jim is correct that the 2 motors on the Evo prevents it from hanging up on the bottom drain.

Con's vs Active 20 are; there is no automation mode so you can not just plug it into a smart plug and program it to run 3 cycles during the night. Both units usually take 2 cycles to get the entire pool sometimes 3. I feel the fine filters in the A20 catch more in my pool than the fine filter in the Evo, I am not getting that fine silt like stuff that I usually get, however Jim did, so I do not know what to make of it. Cleaning the Evo's filters is much quicker and less messy than A20 because I can use a mist which does not splash as much and only takes a minute but I do not think it will last as long, time will tell and if does not last, it will be worth the $50 for the ease and quickness of cleaning. The other big con is I could buy the A20 locally for $100 more than cost of Evo and take it back for repairs during warrantee. In fact 1 month after my warrantee expired on my A30i the motor was replaced buy this local store (where I bought it). but I had complained about the unit previously so they honored the warrantee. I really would like to have that Automation mode and local warrantee but the real question and deciding factor between the 2 is how long will it last, time will tell.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
One more question on this unit.
Looks like in the new app update you can schedule cleanings. Is it safe to leave them in the pool during the week?
I had always been told that the chlorine and salt water would damage over time.
 
35,

I have several robots at different pools.. It does not seem to me that leaving them in the pool, or taking them out of the pool, makes any noticeable difference.

I can't see the point of scheduling anything if it can't be left in the pool. :mrgreen:

I take the robot at my pool out, because I don't like seeing it in my pool, and I only stick it in once or maybe twice a week.

The one's at my rent houses, stay in the pool 24/7/365, unless the tenants take them out when swimming.

Thanks,

Jim R.
 
35,

I have several robots at different pools.. It does not seem to me that leaving them in the pool, or taking them out of the pool, makes any noticeable difference.

I can't see the point of scheduling anything if it can't be left in the pool. :mrgreen:

I take the robot at my pool out, because I don't like seeing it in my pool, and I only stick it in once or maybe twice a week.

The one's at my rent houses, stay in the pool 24/7/365, unless the tenants take them out when swimming.

Thanks,

Jim R.

Thank you sir.
 
Looks like in the new app update you can schedule cleanings. Is it safe to leave them in the pool during the week?

It does not seem to me that leaving them in the pool, or taking them out of the pool, makes any noticeable difference.
I have had the Dolphin 20 and now the Active 20. I take mine out between cleanings when I'm not on vacation...probably because I'm OCD as opposed to any real benefit of taking it out. When I'm on vacation I use the automation feature and leave the cleaner in the pool.
 
  • Like
Reactions: capp35 and Jimrahbe

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
35,

So it turns completely over, on its lid????

Mine does not climb my stairs at all. Maybe has to do with how deep each stair is.. :scratch:

Anyway, first time I have heard that one.

Thanks,

Jim R.
Yes sir, on its lid and tracks just spinning.
Got 30 days to take it back for something similarly priced.
Only other 2 that catch my eye that they have is the A20 and the CC plus with WiFi.
I see the A20 has side jets for stability.
 
My Evo 614 iq does climb my steps or at least 1st 2 or 1st 3, but it really does not clean them because the width of the step is too narrow for it to make a complete 90 before it gets to the next riser and the unit seems to "float" up 1 or 2 steps before it gets turned around and settles back to the bottom. But it has not turned upside down yet. My Active 30i would get to the steps and start a climb but frequently it would get to 90 degrees and spin in its tracks and occasionally flip on its back and could not recover without someone helping it to upright itself. So the active 20 may do the same thing. If I had to choose which is more stable at this point I would say the Evo is. The 2 big areas of con for me are no automation mode where I could have the robot run 3 time or continuously through the night (it sometimes takes 3 cycles to get the complete pool) you can do that with Active 20 using automation mode. the second con is the fine cleaner does not seem to collect as much fine silt as I remember to Active 30i would, but it did do it in Jim's pool, perhaps mine was cleaner. Also I liked the blue light on the A 30i because I could look out window and see if it was still running but this is really a small issue and would be a mute point if I could program it to do 3 cycles a night.
 
  • Like
Reactions: capp35
CT,

Well "in theory" there should not be any debris in behind that white cover at the back of the robot.

It appears to me that water should come out of that area only when you pull the robot out of the pool. When running under water, there is a little float that is supposed to stop water from coming out of the white cover on the back. All the water should be coming out of the suction vent at the top of the unit.

When you pull it out of the water the float, no longer floats, and the door opens to allow all the water to drain out of the back as you lift it up. And "in theory' all the dirt should be trapped inside the filter basket. The filter area is sealed by a gasket at the top of the basket.

That said, we all know how theories often work... :mrgreen:

I get much less dirty water back into my pool with the EVO than I do with my Dolphin S200's..

Thanks,

Jim R.
Jim,
I wonder if either the door or the seal isn't working properly for me. Yesterday when I pulled it out of water all of the hemlock needles it picked up flowed right out the door and back into the pool. At least recently the only thing in basket when I take it out is what sticks to the side of the basket, it rarely has any "loose" debris in basket and pool always looks like it still needs to be vacuumed. Going to have to find a way to test those on pool deck
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20240615_215626075.jpg
    PXL_20240615_215626075.jpg
    303.7 KB · Views: 18
  • PXL_20240615_215554462.jpg
    PXL_20240615_215554462.jpg
    233 KB · Views: 18
  • PXL_20240615_215521124.jpg
    PXL_20240615_215521124.jpg
    277.3 KB · Views: 18
Eric,

As a test, see what happens if you pull the robot up to the surface and then grab it by the handle and at the other end, so that you are pulling it out kind of level..

It seems to me that something is not working..

Thanks,

Jim R.
 
Jim,
Talked to Polaris support yesterday and she said that this was the first she had heard of the 8642IQ / 614IQ flipping backwards, and then tried selling me on one that was $400 more with wheels…..Nah. My M5 with tracks never did it in 10 years.
So in you’re opinion, should I exchange it for another one or go for the S200/ A20, since you have had both?
AMATEUR above ^ said though that his A30i did that a few times though, and so far not his new 614IQ.
🤷🏻‍♂️
 
35,

The basic problem is that pool design has a lot to do with how well any robot works in your specific pool. Unfortunately, the only way to find out how well a robot will work in your pool, is to try it. :(

I have not heard anyone else reporting the EVO flipping over, so it must be your pool.. :poke: :mrgreen:

Since the EVO does not appear to work in your pool, I would try the S200 "style" robot and see how it goes..

Cleaning wise, there is not a lot of difference between the EVO and the Dolphins.. I like the EVO because of the dual traction motor design and am 'hoping' that it will have a longer lifespan, but a long way from knowing if that is true or not..

Thanks,

Jim R.
 
35,

The basic problem is that pool design has a lot to do with how well any robot works in your specific pool. Unfortunately, the only way to find out how well a robot will work in your pool, is to try it. :(

I have not heard anyone else reporting the EVO flipping over, so it must be your pool.. :poke: :mrgreen:

Since the EVO does not appear to work in your pool, I would try the S200 "style" robot and see how it goes..

Cleaning wise, there is not a lot of difference between the EVO and the Dolphins.. I like the EVO because of the dual traction motor design and am 'hoping' that it will have a longer lifespan, but a long way from knowing if that is true or not..

Thanks,

Jim R.
Thank you sir. Wish I could try before I buy.
I did notice that Maytronics has a rebate that ends Sunday.
 
Personal note on using the Lift System.

When the unit comes up to the surface of the water the treads keep running. All I have to do is lift the unit enough for the treads to get traction on the coping and then it "drives" itself out of the pool and a foot or so onto the deck, where the unit then shuts down. My high-mileage back really appreciates this.
 
Jim,
Maybe it was just a fluke.
Ran it 3 times last night and watched it on my steps. It is much more aggressive on my steps than my old M5. Did not turn over this time.
Since I can’t find any more info on the S200 or S300 to assure me they are better, I think I will just keep this one. When I am out of town I will switch it to floor only.
I did notice when watching though, when doing water line it only seemed to move about 10-12” of tile and then go back down. In a video (YouTube) that I saw on the S200/300 looked like the side jet would open and it would do 2-3’. Was that just a promo vid?
Thanks
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support