Need help!! With cloudy pool

Foxrider714

Member
Jun 15, 2021
15
New York
So my pool is a 15x26 oval above ground 4ft chlorine.. I added stabilizer on Friday evening and Saturday morning it was so cloudy I could not even see the bottom.. my pump has been running 24/7 since then I have taken my filter out 2x and cleaned it and shocked it and still nothing.. I have test strips and took water to pool store to get tested and here are my numbers.. I added today (Tuesday) a
phosphates Remover will this help
 

Attachments

  • 96364443-9F29-4792-8DA4-48FD5A2F7E3A.jpeg
    96364443-9F29-4792-8DA4-48FD5A2F7E3A.jpeg
    439.1 KB · Views: 34
  • 7BDCFC5F-280D-4FEA-B829-531549E0FEAF.jpeg
    7BDCFC5F-280D-4FEA-B829-531549E0FEAF.jpeg
    371.6 KB · Views: 32
Welcome to TFP.
It would be much better if you purchase your own test kit - Test Kits Compared as the forum doesn't have a lot of faith in pool store tests. In fact the money you spent on that phosphate remover could have been applied to a good test kit.
If you can believe the pool store result of 70 for CYA (rounded up) then you should really be targeting a FC level of 8-10ppm with an absolute minimum of 5ppm. I suggest you purchase some liquid chlorine - don't use pucks as you will drive your CYA higher which is not good. Bring up your FC and monitor your pool.
Please seriously consider purchasing a proper test kit and then post those results and stay out of a pool store where they want you to purchase unnecessary chemicals.
 
One needs chlorine in the pool to stabilize. It makes little sense to add CYA and no chlorine. Liquid is easiest and best. SWG is even better.

Pool store free results cost too much in bad chemical suggestions. Invest in your pool's health and your own.

Maddie :flower:
 
Yes I will look into a kit..adding the liquid chlorine will get rid of it being so cloudy? I think I am going to drain some water out
What are you trying to achieve by draining? Draining your pool really only helps to lower CYA. Your CYA of 70 (based on pool store results) is not terrible. What you need is chlorine and your own good test kit. Maintain that at proper levels for several days and then see how the pool looks.
 
What are you trying to achieve by draining? Draining your pool really only helps to lower CYA. Your CYA of 70 (based on pool store results) is not terrible. What you need is chlorine and your own good test kit. Maintain that at proper levels for several days and then see how the pool looks.

mom trying to get the pool back to normal and I can’t get rid of the cloudy milky look for days now.. I have my chlorine floater and I shocked the Crud out of it how many times already what kind of liquid chlorine would you recommend?
 
mom trying to get the pool back to normal and I can’t get rid of the cloudy milky look for days now.. I have my chlorine floater and I shocked the Crud out of it how many times already what kind of liquid chlorine would you recommend?
for liquid chlorine, try Walmart, Lowe's, home depot, ACE hardware, if you have them try Ocean State job lot and Menards. It doesn't have to be a specific brand. My local Walmart has had a good supply of Pool Essentials Pool Chlorine which is 10%. Or you can get plain, unscented bleach. No Clorox with Cloromax or whatever, nothing labeled splashless or any of that junk. And seriously, ditch those tabs and the floater - they won't do you any favors unless you have low CYA.
 
mom trying to get the pool back to normal and I can’t get rid of the cloudy milky look for days now.. I have my chlorine floater and I shocked the Crud out of it how many times already what kind of liquid chlorine would you recommend?
As stated by @V___25 you need liquid chlorine (LC) to raise your FC level to 8-10ppm. Buy 10 gals to get you started and stay away from pucks as well for now. Focus on that and you will see the pool start to clear. Both Walmart and Home Depot have pool sections where there should be liquid chlorine. Sometimes it is noted as liquid shock. I would suggest to stay away from granular shock as you get the best bang for the buck with liquid chlorine.
Also, have a little patience with using LC. It mixes quickly but does take time to raise the FC level that you need.
If you do plan to drain then do that first as you just waste LC. However, I think you can avoid that and just focus on raising LC. It would be good to get that test kit so you can ensure you maintain at the 8-10ppm. If you bring your pool sample to Leslie with a FC of 8ppm they will try to sell something to clear your water and say let your FC level drop to 4. That is a round robin you do not want to get into as they do not understand the FC/CYA relationship. The TFP methodology works for thousands of people. Give it a try but you can not mix TFP recommendations with pool store recommendations as they are in conflict with one another.
 
As stated by @V___25 you need liquid chlorine (LC) to raise your FC level to 8-10ppm. Buy 10 gals to get you started and stay away from pucks as well for now. Focus on that and you will see the pool start to clear. Both Walmart and Home Depot have pool sections where there should be liquid chlorine. Sometimes it is noted as liquid shock. I would suggest to stay away from granular shock as you get the best bang for the buck with liquid chlorine.
Also, have a little patience with using LC. It mixes quickly but does take time to raise the FC level that you need.
If you do plan to drain then do that first as you just waste LC. However, I think you can avoid that and just focus on raising LC. It would be good to get that test kit so you can ensure you maintain at the 8-10ppm. If you bring your pool sample to Leslie with a FC of 8ppm they will try to sell something to clear your water and say let your FC level drop to 4. That is a round robin you do not want to get into as they do not understand the FC/CYA relationship. The TFP methodology works for thousands of people. Give it a try but you can not mix TFP recommendations with pool store recommendations as they are in conflict with one another.
Thank you for a good write up I’m looking to see who has it in stock now but a lot of them say liquid shock? Would that be the same? And you think 10gal I need now to put in?? Oh boy lol
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Will this be ok?
This will work as it is 6%. Not sure how much it costs. The lower the % of sodium hypochlorite then the more volume you need to add to reach your targeted FC level. A 10% or 12.5% LC may cost a little more but gets you there with less jugs. However if that is all you can find then go with it. No need to spend time doing a lot of searching from store to store.
I said 10 gals just as an estimate because once you raise to 8-10 ppm you need to keep it at that level. So it is not a 1 time event.

So I based the following on the pool volume of 10,000 gals noted by Leslie's. If you go with 6% LC then each 1 gal jug will raise your FC by 6ppm. Therefore add 2 gallons initially and mix well with pumps running. Check the FC level after 3 hours and may need to add more LC. Use the data that 1 gal = 6ppm for your 10,000 gal pool (If the volume is different or if you use a different % of chlorine then come back as the info will change).
Good Luck
 
This will work as it is 6%. Not sure how much it costs. The lower the % of sodium hypochlorite then the more volume you need to add to reach your targeted FC level. A 10% or 12.5% LC may cost a little more but gets you there with less jugs. However if that is all you can find then go with it. No need to spend time doing a lot of searching from store to store.
I said 10 gals just as an estimate because once you raise to 8-10 ppm you need to keep it at that level. So it is not a 1 time event.

So I based the following on the pool volume of 10,000 gals noted by Leslie's. If you go with 6% LC then each 1 gal jug will raise your FC by 6ppm. Therefore add 2 gallons initially and mix well with pumps running. Check the FC level after 3 hours and may need to add more LC. Use the data that 1 gal = 6ppm for your 10,000 gal pool (If the volume is different or if you use a different % of chlorine then come back as the info will change).
Good Luck
Thank you so much I’ll let you know how it works out
 
So I put in 2 gal last night and went out in the morning and still very cloudy and that white particles some what there.. i checked my FC this morning and didn’t read anything so I put 2 more in and left for work.. by me doing this going to help or should I just wait till weekend to keep a better eye on it so I can add more LC (slam) my pool better?
 
If waiting till the weekend is necessary do what you need to do.

I would request that you fill out a Signature Line, found under <Settings> and telling what your pool size, finish, describe water features, equipment, how you chlorinate and how you test. This helps us enormously to answer you without repeated questions about your pool.

I'm particularly curious about your filter at this point and what attention it may require?

Maddie :flower:
 
So I put in 2 gal last night and went out in the morning and still very cloudy and that white particles some what there.. i checked my FC this morning and didn’t read anything so I put 2 more in and left for work.. by me doing this going to help or should I just wait till weekend to keep a better eye on it so I can add more LC (slam) my pool better?
When you do a SLAM you need to be there to monitor it as well a test every 3-4 hrs during daylight time. So if that works better to wait till Friday or Saturday then so be it. No need to add LC now although every little bit helps but when you start to SLAM ensure you have minimum 10 gals on hand. As noted below 1 gal raises FC 6ppm based on your pool volume of 10,000 gals and using 6% LC. Your Leslie's pool test showed CYA of 70 so that needs to be verified but if that is correct then your SLAM target is 28ppm. So you will need 5 gals (5gal x 6ppm =30ppm assume starting from 0 FC) to reach SLAM level, then you need to maintain it at that level for several days. Be prepared to add a gall every 3-4 hours initially, but that will need to be confirmed by testing. You also need to brush the walls and floor routinely plus keep your pump circulating.

With regard to your comment on your DE filter, backwash it before you start the SLAM and monitor the filter pressure.
By cleaning it daily - do you mean you are backwashing it daily? If so, do you have enough DE on hand to replenish what you have removed?

Keep us posted and as requested earlier - fill out your signature with pertinent details regarding your pool and test kit info.
 
So I just wanted to let you all know my pool is finally back to being so clear it makes me happy again lol.. so I am not going to use the hockey pucks anymore in my floater because I think that’s what stoping me from keeping my numbers in check.. I will keep shocking once a week if need be but now here is my problem, I still can’t get a reading of free and total chlorine.. so I was looking on here and put my numbers in and I should still put more LC in my pool?
 
You must add liquid chlorine EVERY DAY to maintain the FC at the target range level for your CYA. EVERY DAY.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.