So I recently got my new liner installed. Majority of the work was done by one guy and he struggled with liner being very tight around the corners a lot. Told me before it's all about preparation and cleaning and actual liner hookup takes him half an hour.
He spent half a day wrestling with it and then let it hang overnight, partially exposing the concrete shell. Came back with an expert and they finished it somewhat next day and few days later finally tucked the corners in when the water was almost to the level. Secured with the liner lock. Ironically he told me upfront that properly installed liner doesn't need a lock.
I took a swim today for the very first time and looked and felt around the deep end. The floor around the main drain feels like a moon surface. The shell is all around concrete. In a very decent shape. It feels like there are rocks or loose concrete chips all around. Some of them sticking out maybe 1/3 of an inch compared to the rest of the surface. Some of the relatively sharp to the point where i see the liner being slightly whiter shade because of the stretch.
I imagine any pushing off the bottom at the deep end will wear those point relatively quick. And I have a robotic pool cleaner. Ironically again, the guy was telling me that he advises people with sand bottoms that have some irregularities not to use the robots, since they will wear the spots where the liner sticks out.
So I'm at the loss what to do with this. He will for sure tell me it's going to be ok. And he guarantees his work for couple of years. But I haven't seen that in writing. He would probably promise to fix it if it develops a leak. But I assume I won't hear from him if it develops a problem down the road.
My previous liner served me 20 years. I can take care of it chemistry wise and shouldn't expect a premature failure.
He is coming back in a couple of days to finish few things - few spots have some wrinkles. I paid the deposit for the liner, but I still owe him $1600 for the install.
So the options that i see are as follows.
1. Do nothing, hope for the best.
2. Get something in writing acknowledging this specific problem and maybe how he would address it based on the timeline?
3. Ask for reinstall and have him cover the new water (~1k).
The last one is almost a loss for him. It would make it more sense for him to walk away and leave me with $1600 not paid vs do the same work again and paid for the water.
He seems like a decent guy and I don't want to shaft him, but the same time I'm pretty unhappy and most likely have a much shortened lifespan of the brand new liner.
What should I do?
edit: does the deposit ($3600) typically goes to the liner manufacturer it its entirety? is there any kickback to the installer?
He spent half a day wrestling with it and then let it hang overnight, partially exposing the concrete shell. Came back with an expert and they finished it somewhat next day and few days later finally tucked the corners in when the water was almost to the level. Secured with the liner lock. Ironically he told me upfront that properly installed liner doesn't need a lock.
I took a swim today for the very first time and looked and felt around the deep end. The floor around the main drain feels like a moon surface. The shell is all around concrete. In a very decent shape. It feels like there are rocks or loose concrete chips all around. Some of them sticking out maybe 1/3 of an inch compared to the rest of the surface. Some of the relatively sharp to the point where i see the liner being slightly whiter shade because of the stretch.
I imagine any pushing off the bottom at the deep end will wear those point relatively quick. And I have a robotic pool cleaner. Ironically again, the guy was telling me that he advises people with sand bottoms that have some irregularities not to use the robots, since they will wear the spots where the liner sticks out.
So I'm at the loss what to do with this. He will for sure tell me it's going to be ok. And he guarantees his work for couple of years. But I haven't seen that in writing. He would probably promise to fix it if it develops a leak. But I assume I won't hear from him if it develops a problem down the road.
My previous liner served me 20 years. I can take care of it chemistry wise and shouldn't expect a premature failure.
He is coming back in a couple of days to finish few things - few spots have some wrinkles. I paid the deposit for the liner, but I still owe him $1600 for the install.
So the options that i see are as follows.
1. Do nothing, hope for the best.
2. Get something in writing acknowledging this specific problem and maybe how he would address it based on the timeline?
3. Ask for reinstall and have him cover the new water (~1k).
The last one is almost a loss for him. It would make it more sense for him to walk away and leave me with $1600 not paid vs do the same work again and paid for the water.
He seems like a decent guy and I don't want to shaft him, but the same time I'm pretty unhappy and most likely have a much shortened lifespan of the brand new liner.
What should I do?
edit: does the deposit ($3600) typically goes to the liner manufacturer it its entirety? is there any kickback to the installer?
Last edited: