Please help me understand

Wrong one but steps are also stained
It’s a yellow ish stain that area drawn hasnt grown but it has grown around the sides. My fc is 14 amd I vacuum and brush constantly I never had algae. My cya was 65 per Taylor test and it’s pouring rain so I’m not adding anymore chlorine- rain will not dilute CYA… I was gonna drain more but I can’t THUNDER!
Yes I think it got worse after the algecide!
 
Don't worry about the staining or anything else right now. Continue to maintain the SLAM weather permitting. We tackle algae first, then stains. The chlorine is aggravating the metals, that's normal. Relax and enjoy the rain. :cheers:
 
  • Like
Reactions: jackieRN
Don't worry about the staining or anything else right now. Continue to maintain the SLAM weather permitting. We tackle algae first, then stains. The chlorine is aggravating the metals, that's normal. Relax and enjoy the rain. :cheers:
When did we talk about slam? I see what it is but since my cya is 65 I’m planning on maintaining the recommended FC until or if I drain more water. I don’t have algae. The water is sparkling clean. Why would I need to slam if everything looks good?
 
Ps- is the magnetic stir thing for 50$ worth it?

The speed/smart stir... Absolutely! :goodjob:

I will second that, Absolutely…. You will be annoyed with yourself for not having it from the beginning.
I have a second mains powered one just incase my batteries run out and I have used it.
 
I think you can see the pool staining now which actually is getting worse. It’s still raining so I’m dumping in a gallon of chlorine until I can test tomorrow and my speed stirrer arrives Monday
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2627.jpeg
    IMG_2627.jpeg
    828 KB · Views: 7
  • Like
Reactions: Texas Splash
When you get the speed stir, let's start fresh with a whole new set of test results when your schedule permits. The speed stir really helps with testing. I don't recall, are you using any polyfill in the skimmer to try and catch some iron? In your case the water looks clear, so you're in one of those situations where the metals seems to be going right to the liner versus remaining suspended in the water, but I was curious.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
When you get the speed stir, let's start fresh with a whole new set of test results when your schedule permits. The speed stir really helps with testing. I don't recall, are you using any polyfill in the skimmer to try and catch some iron? In your case the water looks clear, so you're in one of those situations where the metals seems to be going right to the liner versus remaining suspended in the water, but I was curious.
No I don’t know what that is(polyfil) and I agree because the staining has gotten so much worse. It’s from the cya and high chlorine combining right or something like that?
I’m guessing a bottle of metal out won’t work since it’s stained. Anyway I tried that earlier. Ugh this is not fun
 
I don’t know what that is(polyfil)
Polyfill is the same kind of stuff they use in pillows and other items as a form of stuffing. You can get it locally or online. It's used commonly here at TFP to help trap iron particles.

full
 
It’s from the cya and high chlorine combining right or something like that?
Iron reacts because of 3 things: The amount of iron in the water, an elevated pH, and elevated FC. The more iron you can remove, the less influence the other things have on it.
 
I’m guessing a bottle of metal out won’t work since it’s stained.
You might try some of those products at some point. Some products are relatively successful at pulling a stain off the surface. When stains are lifted, they remain in a soluble form in the water. At that point you don't see it and it can't be filter. What many people do is just live with it until water temps fall again and they do an AA treatment. An AA treatment lifts stains but requires an FC of basically zero which can allow algae to form, that's why colder water is best for that. Some people still do AA treatments in the hotter months, but it comes with that added risk of algae.

 
Hey Jackie, this thread is quickly approaching the 100 mark, so it's hard to go back and remember everything. :crazy: Humor me please for a refresher of where your pool stands right now. Still no algae correct? We dismissed the need for a SLAM, or at least you are not doing one at the moment. You have been slowly but surely exchanging water in an attempt to lower the CYA. That's been the biggest thing right now. While doing that, also trying to maintain an elevated FC level commensurate with the high CYA to prevent algae. Unfortunately, while keeping the FC a little elevated, you discovered there is iron in the water which has caused some staining.

Am I still on track?
 
No I don’t know what that is(polyfil) and I agree because the staining has gotten so much worse. It’s from the cya and high chlorine combining right or something like that?
I’m guessing a bottle of metal out won’t work since it’s stained. Anyway I tried that earlier. Ugh this is not fun
Actually tested my cua tested 60 today o did it 4 x and ph was over 8 and chlorine was super high so that explains it. I can’t seem to keep ph down I’m using ph down when it’s not storming - but I’m not doing much else till I get that stirrer - I ripped open an old pillow and put poly fill in - I’ll update when I get that thing and we can talk trash😊
 
  • Like
Reactions: Texas Splash
Ooooh! 60 is MUCH better. :goodjob: That's the tough thing about being forced to maintain an elevated FC over 10 when your CYA is high, it messes with the pH test. But now you can adjust things more normally. :crazy: No more water exchanges needed at this time.

Look at the chart below. Find a CYA of 60 and you can see your "ideal" FC zone is 7-9 and no lower than 5. You can let the FC fall a bit now. When the FC hits 10 or below, take a new pH test to validate and adjust as needed. Those two things "should" help reduce any further staining.

full
 
Hi Texas… I got my speed stir kit finally, first kit came with no bar lol
As a refresher I never had algae, but was battling cya.
Today readings with stir bar…
Ph 7.4
Fc 4
TA 80
CH 220
CYA 60
I know I need chlorine I’ll read the book unless yo u wanna hurry and tell me 😘
We had rain again today and it will rain Friday. It’s hot and sunny now so maybe I should go heavy we are having swimmers tomorrow (maybe).
Thanks for your help I thing I have the hang of this now!!
Except for guessing how much liquid chlorine I use 10%
 
  • Like
Reactions: Texas Splash
Those are very good numbers. :goodjob: Yes, a bit more chlorine would be good. FYI - In your 20K pool, one gallon of 10% liquid chlorine is about 5 ppm of FC. If you add a gallon now you should be in good shape. Then, based on your work schedule, find a routine of how much (and when) to add liquid chlorine each day or two since we know pools love chlorine. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: jackieRN
That’s so much for all your help. I’m very proud of myself for overcoming the overwhelming look of the reagent bottles and powders in 2006c. And now I’m a pro with my magnetic stir kit! Goodbye pool store!
Those are very good numbers. :goodjob: Yes, a bit more chlorine would be good. FYI - In your 20K pool, one gallon of 10% liquid chlorine is about 5 ppm of FC. If you add a gallon now you should be in good shape. Then, based on your work schedule, find a routine of how much (and when) to add liquid chlorine each day or two since we know pools love chlorine. :)
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.