New Pool Owner - Green Pool!

So if the water is still green after several days of a diligent slam, something is off. I’m wondering if the CYA reagent has perhaps been compromised, though it’s usually very stable. What is the expiration date on those reagents? I think the kit typically comes with a few bottles. Maybe try the CYA test with a different bottle?

The one test we do trust the pool stores a bit in is metals. Could you get a pool store test and let us know the metal content for iron and copper?
All the CYA reagent bottles say best by 3/23, but I’ll definitely try using a different bottle next time. I’ll run to a different pool store tomorrow that I know will give me a printout with the test results, so I can share it easily. I’ll make sure to ask about the metals tests in case they don’t do it by default or something.

By the way, should I be seeing bubbles forming along the liner on the side of the pool too? I have assumed they are from gas released when the chlorine is breaking stuff down, is that right?
 
Alright, got the test done at a pool store, see the attached picture. This water sample was collected just after I finished work, and before I added chlorine to bring FC back up to 12 ppm. I got a reading of 7 with my test, so seeing their 6.87 gives me more confidence I’m testing FC correctly. Also, the CYA level they got was 32, which helps since I was having trouble getting a result myself.

As for metals, no iron, and 0.1 ppm copper. Their paper recommends to add something called GLB Sequa-Sol for that, but what do you guys think? Is the copper an issue?

They also said Calcium Hardness is low, but I know I read in the Pool School here in a vinyl pool that doesn’t matter, so I’m not concerned with that.

Finally, after explaining to them he situation about my pool being green for so long, their recommendation was this: “Wait 2-3 days without adding any chlorine, then add 5 gallons of liquid shock at once at night”. Not gonna lie, the idea of adding a bunch of shock at once came to mind, because before joining TFP I watched a video that explained how much more effective adding 3 gallons of chlorine at once is than adding 1 a day for 3 days, but I don’t want to do anything without discussing here, because you guys are the ones I trust, and I don’t want to mess anything up.

Right now my plan is to just continue maintaining 12 ppm and brushing/vacuuming each day, and hope for improvement, but the urge to pour several gallons of shock in at once one of these nights is growing. Could that possibly hurt the process? Is it a myth that it would be more effective?
 

Attachments

  • 9ABBB24B-6B5E-42B2-B771-1D58ECCC1026.jpeg
    9ABBB24B-6B5E-42B2-B771-1D58ECCC1026.jpeg
    344.8 KB · Views: 12
Do your own testing. You have a quality test kit. We do not even look at pool store tests.

Try to save your test results in Poolmath. It makes it much easier for us to see what you are seeing. Right now there is no test data shown in your Poolmath logs.

Follow the SLAM process. The large dump of chlorine they suggest can damage your liner.
 
Do your own testing. You have a quality test kit. We do not even look at pool store tests.

Try to save your test results in Poolmath. It makes it much easier for us to see what you are seeing. Right now there is no test data shown in your Poolmath logs.

Follow the SLAM process. The large dump of chlorine they suggest can damage your liner.
Oh I didn’t realize the pool math app could keep history, or that you could see it! And I was really just looking for their iron test as someone above recommended.

I’ll definitely start logging in the app!
 
Stick with it. You seem to be doing everything right. If it doesn’t improve after a few more days let’s ask some more experts for help.
 
Stick with it. You seem to be doing everything right. If it doesn’t improve after a few more days let’s ask some more experts for help.
Thanks, I will. It’s possible there has been improving a little lately, it’s just hard to tell because it’s still pretty green. I swore I could almost see the brush on the floor of the pool today when I brushed, but I worry about confirmation bias, and don’t want to get excited for nothing.
 
Last edited:
Hey TFP! Just a little update, as I vacuum the pool this fine evening for the first time I’m seeing clearly the bottom is blue as I vacuum up what’s laying on it. I swore the water was getting less foggy every day, but this proves it. The SLAM, though taking a while, is working! Hopefully just a few more days to a blue pool!
 
any update?
Still not blue, but very clearly better each day now. Yesterday when I checked it the first time I could see the bottom clearly all the way around. It was covered with green (dead algae, I’m guessing?) so I just keep vacuuming and brushing every day and maintaining the FC at 12 ppm.

I’ll see if I can get a good picture to share today!
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Still not blue, but very clearly better each day now. Yesterday when I checked it the first time I could see the bottom clearly all the way around. It was covered with green (dead algae, I’m guessing?) so I just keep vacuuming and brushing every day and maintaining the FC at 12 ppm.

I’ll see if I can get a good picture to share today!
The pictures I mentioned. Just before I vacuumed and brushed this morning:
 

Attachments

  • 66915917-CB75-4A5F-989C-ADEE2B367506.jpeg
    66915917-CB75-4A5F-989C-ADEE2B367506.jpeg
    301.5 KB · Views: 21
  • 94496B7C-809F-4EB7-9920-FCE09656E2E8.jpeg
    94496B7C-809F-4EB7-9920-FCE09656E2E8.jpeg
    192.2 KB · Views: 21
It’s looking less green and more blue now! I can’t believe it’s finally happening!

Last night I took 2 hours to vacuum, clean the filter (cartidge), brush and adjust the FC. I suppose I now need to get ready for transitioning out of the SLAM, as it should be coming up here soon. Should the water actually get totally clear, or will I need to add some sort of clarifier or something probably?
 

Attachments

  • 6822FCEF-BD2D-4341-AE5D-6D377F6CF88C.jpeg
    6822FCEF-BD2D-4341-AE5D-6D377F6CF88C.jpeg
    233.7 KB · Views: 16
It’s looking less green and more blue now! I can’t believe it’s finally happening!

Last night I took 2 hours to vacuum, clean the filter (cartidge), brush and adjust the FC. I suppose I now need to get ready for transitioning out of the SLAM, as it should be coming up here soon. Should the water actually get totally clear, or will I need to add some sort of clarifier or something probably?
Kenny,
POP (pool owner patience) needed. You're not there yet but moving in the right direction. A good few days for sure.
 
Kenny,
POP (pool owner patience) needed. You're not there yet but moving in the right direction. A good few days for sure.
Considering we're now on the third week of SLAM, I'm totally good waiting a few more days! I'm just over the moon to see that it doesn't look so opaquely green as it did for over a month (I had some failed shock attempts before joining TFP and learning about SLAM)
 
Don't add clarifiers. They just gum up the filters. Keep that filter clean too :)
Oh I’m on that watching the pressure on the filter every time I go out there! Even when it doesn’t go up, I’ve still been cleaning it every few days minimum, and it’s made a huge difference.

It looked much clearer this afternoon, can’t wait to see what it looks like in the morning.
 
I would also re-check the CYA to be sure it isn't higher the what you're slamming for. If it's higher then you're not attaining slam level. Have seen this scenario personally before,
I checked it to be safe, it’s definitely not higher! If anything, it’s a little low, but not by much. I’ll probably add a little more stabilizer tomorrow to try to get it properly at 30. I can’t really tell where it’s at when it’s under, since the black dot for the test doesn’t quite disappear (it seems to come close though)
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.