Inconsistent pool coping width. Am I being too picky?

Day215

Member
Apr 14, 2019
8
Rocklin ca
Hello,
We’re currently in the middle of our
37’ x19’ IG build. The decking contractor that had been sub’ed out by the PB, recently poured the coping and the sundeck. The remaining decking is being done by my own concrete guy at a late date. The contract listed a 12” coping width along with the raised sundeck.

After it was poured I noticed several inconsistencies in the work.

1. The coping has three spots that are clearly wider than the surrounding areas. Average coping width is about 12.5” but there are two areas that measure 14” and 17”. In my opinion the forms weren’t set up properly, and it double checked the day of the pour.

2. Expansion joints on the sundeck are sloppy and have several “holes” in the joint itself.

3. Top sundeck stair edge wasn’t finished out smoothly, and had several uneven spots.

4. The plastic coping edge above the tile line is pushed out approx 1/2” from the pool edge. It looks like the cantilever form shifted as the were pouring. The edge is now backed by concrete so there is no way of making it flush again.

5. One small 2’ section of coping is slightly sloped towards the pool. It’s within the lines on a bubble level, but you tell its sloped.

6. There is a small high spot on the corner of the sundeck.

I addressed my concerns with the PB and he setup a meeting with the decking guy for tomorrow. The more I look at it, the less visible certain things become, but I’m still not happy. The stairs and the expansion joints are easy fixes, but the coping is a different story. Am I being too picky when it comes to these issues, specifically the coping inconsistencies?
 
Your hard earned money be a picky as you feel like being. Two or three different sized tiles is not good unless they discussed with you. Grout joints should be full!!!


Post a picture or 4.

John
I’ll try to get some photos later today. I guess I should have been more specific. The coping is a cantilever form with poured concrete. The forms were obviously inconsistent in width and the results are apparent. I really don’t want to go through the ordeal of having it all ripped out, but I’m my eye is drawn to the wide spot every time I look at it.
 
I really don’t want to go through the ordeal of having it all ripped out, but I’m my eye is drawn to the wide spot every time I look at it.

You need to determine what solution you want that you think the contractor will accept.

Any redo of concrete may not match perfectly in color.

While it bothers you now, no one will notice it when they are enjoying your pool.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pooldv and Day215
Can the coping be cut down with a concrete saw?

The high spot on the sundeck can be ground down abs refinished. The stairs can be touched up along with the expansion joint. The wonky width of the coping would require demolition and pouring it over again.

I agree most wouldn’t notice, but with the money I’m spending, I would expect a little more.
 

Attachments

  • 5F384379-30D9-4F06-9D33-632B49B520DF.jpeg
    5F384379-30D9-4F06-9D33-632B49B520DF.jpeg
    582.1 KB · Views: 143
  • 138BDFAA-0F52-4538-9F02-BEA28FC02B05.jpeg
    138BDFAA-0F52-4538-9F02-BEA28FC02B05.jpeg
    460.9 KB · Views: 145
  • 5F347B48-85EE-4D8B-BE70-2CB5A5A928C3.jpeg
    5F347B48-85EE-4D8B-BE70-2CB5A5A928C3.jpeg
    488.9 KB · Views: 142
  • 37B9E4F4-F09D-4103-A3BB-657436AECBC2.jpeg
    37B9E4F4-F09D-4103-A3BB-657436AECBC2.jpeg
    696.3 KB · Views: 141
  • AC30BE5A-CEF4-443A-A26C-B06289789C77.jpeg
    AC30BE5A-CEF4-443A-A26C-B06289789C77.jpeg
    547.5 KB · Views: 137
  • C76C1D98-E0D5-4B2F-9E8D-588821FA0325.jpeg
    C76C1D98-E0D5-4B2F-9E8D-588821FA0325.jpeg
    639.5 KB · Views: 141
  • 7AEB869D-CE6A-4F02-8C93-8E151F5F3841.jpeg
    7AEB869D-CE6A-4F02-8C93-8E151F5F3841.jpeg
    505.1 KB · Views: 142
  • A502055C-4203-469B-85E8-70B8BFA41DC1.jpeg
    A502055C-4203-469B-85E8-70B8BFA41DC1.jpeg
    448 KB · Views: 138
Is the above what they offered as a way to fix the problems? What are your thoughts after sleeping on it?

There was no pride of work show in those jobs :( It would be a big NOPE for me and a total redo!

Yeah you don't want the mess and time of a tear out but that is what they are counting on! They have got by with it so many times they don't even really try any more and it shows on this job.
 
Wow.. Does not look like you got the "A" team for this one... Did see any of them with a tape measure? "Free form" does not mean "Free to do what I please". I would not be satisfied with that lack of quality.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Just make sure they are extra careful not to damage any tile. I'm going through this myself, however, they finally agreed to replace bad sections of poured in place coping after pool was completed. They removed the sections of cracked coping which ended up being 1/3 of the pool. I'm now just going to pay my landscaper to remove the remaining and replace with precast.
 
The owner of the pool company came and took a look. I didn’t say much of anything, before he said they would have the sub tear it out and replace. He said if it wasn’t good enough for his backyard, then it’s not good enough for mine.

We have other contractors scheduled in the next few weeks and this is adding to my stress level. In the end I’m sure it’ll be worth repairing, but it sure feels like it’ll never get finished.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.