Good news, I think. I left the cover off all day and turned the eyeball upwards to start aerating the pool. Here were the number I tested this evening.
FC-14
CC-1
TA-80
The pH looked like it was right at 6.8, but based on our previous conversations it seems like the pH is actually lower than what is showing up.
I will try to pick up some Borax tomorrow to add.
I did feel a little more comfortable doing the tests this time so hopefully that means they are a little more accurate. The one bad thing was, I ran the CYA test again and it seemed like the dot disappeared at 90. It was getting dark and cloudy, so that may have been part of it.