FC jump from adding acid?

Update:

Over the 4'th of July holiday weekend I decided to try an experiment at lowering TA. 8:30 AM July 3 I added 32 oz of 14% HCl and reduced the pH from 7.7 to 7.0, as checked a few minutes later allowing my swim current to mix the pool. There was no measurable change in TA. Poolmath predicted -10 ppm TA which is within the +/- 1 drop precision of the test so it's not terribly surprising there was no measured change. I then turned on my SPA spillover mode which runs the SPA jets at full blast generating lots of aeration closed the pool cover and left it run.

Checking the chemistry at 4PM the same day I found the PH had risen back to 7.6, TA still measured 60. Left the spillover mode running all night.

8:30 AM July 4 PH now measures 8.0, TA still 60. At this point I added another 32 oz of HCl, let it mix and checked the chemistry PH 7.2, TA 50. Left the spillover/aeration running.
4:30 PM July 4 PH 7.6, TA back to 60. At this point I shutdown the SPA spillover and went back to normal operation.

The one thing I learned from this experiment: 24 hrs of the SPA running causes as much pH rise as I would normally see in 4 days with normal usage (SPA running ~30 minutes/day). From this I conclude that the SPA usage is not a major factor the pH rise, maybe 10% of the total.

In the two weeks since the Holiday the TA has crept back up to 70 as I have been adding acid couple of times per week when the pH reaches 7.8 or higher. I have been slowly adding additional CYA as well with the intent to bring it up to 60 ppm.
 
Added CYA adds some cyanurate alkalinity to your TA.
Ah, good point. Do you know the magnitude? Is it 1:1? ie would 10ppm of CYA increase TA by 10ppm?
Regarding the fill water I had mentioned that earlier in the thread. The pool is covered when not in use. I know from testing (turning off the autofill and carefully monitoring the water level) the losses are less than 1% of the volume per week. The fill water TA is 120 ppm, so I would expect to be gaining 1.2ppm/week from the fill.
 
It may not be quite as bad as I made it sound. Quoting from the email from the maintenance company that did the startup:
25 ounces were added with diluted acid. We prepare solutions before arrival.
Per the product label the recommended amount would have been ~ 16oz for my pool volume. In any event that was 9 months ago, and per @JoyfulNoise the HEDP has probably decomposed by now.
 
All I know is that the technician arrived with the gallon jug (label pictured several posts above) and added half to the pool shortly after it was filled, and then added the second half a few days later. When I queried the owner of the service about the quantity via email I got the response quoted above. So sounds like the had prepared a mix in the gallon jug with 25 oz of the Beautec stuff some amount of acid, and the rest water.
 
So sounds like the had prepared a mix in the gallon jug with 25 oz of the Beautec stuff some amount of acid, and the rest water.
It's a really bad practice to mix chemicals.

Certain combinations can explode or create really dangerous, toxic, corrosive gases.

It also is really bad practice to have a jug that has a label that does not accurately describe the contents.

Most chemicals say on the label "Do NOT Mix with other Chemicals!".


1657911809839.png

 
Last edited:
Honestly, with lots of pool builders, it's the "Wild West" in terms of their chemical knowledge. Heck, lots of pool builders don't even own pools themselves ... hmmmm .... maybe they know something we don't :unsure::unsure: ... anyway, it's not at all shocking that they'd mix up their own cocktails and potions and then they swear that they learned the secret from some ancient Buddhist monk whose meditation pool never turned green and whose waters could heal all ailments. In other words, 99% of them are full of bull puckey ... so that's why TFP exists - do as WE say not as THEY do ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamesW

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.