Do I need to kill algae before treating for high phosphates

I have an update and of course a question. I accomplished a ~33% drain and refill of the pool (CYA decreased from 60 to 40). Not sure how I got so close to my desired result without a math major performing all sorts of measurements and calculus calculations on the pool but I'm apparently a good guesser. I did an OCLT and after performing FC measurement 2 of 2 this morning I decided I wasn't particularly happy with how I performed the measurements but I'm pretty confident the two were within 1.5 ppm if not lower and I plan to be more careful with tonight's and tomorrow's AM measurements.

I consider my algae issue not a particularly bad one. The water never had any shade of green to it. Although I had some light algae growing on the walls that got significant sun my main issue was algae accumulating on the bottom. And I'm pretty confident it wasn't growing on the bottom because if I just waved the skimmer net within a foot or so of the algae it would be whisked off the bottom and stay floating for a period of time. I'm not a chemist and I'm not sure this is the correct term but to me it seemed like this algae was "precipitating" out of the water and dropping to the bottom.

I have been brushing the pool, especially the bottom the past 2 days (and before that) so that the filter can suck up as much as possible. I have read plenty on this site since I started this thread and well know what the end game is (CC < 0.5, OCLT < 1.0 and clear water). So my question is this: The past two days the algae falling to the bottom has decreased dramatically but there is still a small amount. Should I not consider myself done with the SLAM until ALL visible algae on the bottom is gone or if tomorrow AM the result of the OCLT is < 1.0 and CC < 0.5 can I consider myself done?

I guess what I am asking is this: is the small amount of visible algae sitting on the bottom likely still living or is it possible that, although visible, it is dead and will be eventually consumed by the chlorine and filter. I know the answer is probably "why take a chance" and I do not plan on taking that chance but if anyone has experience with this type of "end game call" I'd be interested.
 
Should I not consider myself done with the SLAM until ALL visible algae on the bottom is gone or if tomorrow AM the result of the OCLT is < 1.0 and CC < 0.5 can I consider myself done?
No. Pool should be clear, clear. No algae, dead or alive. Your pool should look like these...Link-->How Clear is TFP Clear?

Sincerely,
PoolStored
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mdragger88
I have an update and of course a question. I accomplished a ~33% drain and refill of the pool (CYA decreased from 60 to 40). Not sure how I got so close to my desired result without a math major performing all sorts of measurements and calculus calculations on the pool but I'm apparently a good guesser. I did an OCLT and after performing FC measurement 2 of 2 this morning I decided I wasn't particularly happy with how I performed the measurements but I'm pretty confident the two were within 1.5 ppm if not lower and I plan to be more careful with tonight's and tomorrow's AM measurements.

I consider my algae issue not a particularly bad one. The water never had any shade of green to it. Although I had some light algae growing on the walls that got significant sun my main issue was algae accumulating on the bottom. And I'm pretty confident it wasn't growing on the bottom because if I just waved the skimmer net within a foot or so of the algae it would be whisked off the bottom and stay floating for a period of time. I'm not a chemist and I'm not sure this is the correct term but to me it seemed like this algae was "precipitating" out of the water and dropping to the bottom.

I have been brushing the pool, especially the bottom the past 2 days (and before that) so that the filter can suck up as much as possible. I have read plenty on this site since I started this thread and well know what the end game is (CC < 0.5, OCLT < 1.0 and clear water). So my question is this: The past two days the algae falling to the bottom has decreased dramatically but there is still a small amount. Should I not consider myself done with the SLAM until ALL visible algae on the bottom is gone or if tomorrow AM the result of the OCLT is < 1.0 and CC < 0.5 can I consider myself done?

I guess what I am asking is this: is the small amount of visible algae sitting on the bottom likely still living or is it possible that, although visible, it is dead and will be eventually consumed by the chlorine and filter. I know the answer is probably "why take a chance" and I do not plan on taking that chance but if anyone has experience with this type of "end game call" I'd be interested.
You might describe how you are doing the FC test. It’s one of those where you be super confident in since you keep adding drops until the solution changes from pink to totally clear.
 
Dead algae was recently alive-
once no more dead algae remains & you have passed the other
Overnight Chlorine Loss Test criteria you can be assured you have truly eradicated it. Don’t stop until you pass ALL 3 end of slam criteria. It’s much easier to maintain slam level until you’re certain than to quit early only to have to start over again soon down the road.
 
Dead algae was recently alive-
once no more dead algae remains & you have passed the other
Overnight Chlorine Loss Test criteria you can be assured you have truly eradicated it. Don’t stop until you pass ALL 3 end of slam criteria. It’s much easier to maintain slam level until you’re certain than to quit early only to have to start over again soon down the road.
> Don’t stop until you pass ALL 3 end of slam criteria.

I wasn't planning on it but I'm an engineer. I wonder what to do when I pass all 3 criteria and I see a trace of green when I sweep the bottom. I guess I was looking for people's similar experiences but now that I think of it, people in the know in these forums don't have all that much experience in this because they keep their pools balanced and don't need to SLAM once they ARE in the know.
 
> Don’t stop until you pass ALL 3 end of slam criteria.

I wasn't planning on it but I'm an engineer. I wonder what to do when I pass all 3 criteria and I see a trace of green when I sweep the bottom. I guess I was looking for people's similar experiences but now that I think of it, people in the know in these forums don't have all that much experience in this because they keep their pools balanced and don't need to SLAM once they ARE in the know.
Once you pass All 3
✅CC is 0.5 or lower;
✅You pass an Overnight Chlorine Loss Test
AND
✅the water is clear.
(Crystal Clear w/no algae dead or alive)

If you maintain your fc above minimum for your cya thereafter you shouldn’t have any traces of green when you sweep the bottom.
If you see such it’s slam time.
 
I wonder what to do when I pass all 3 criteria and I see a trace of green when I sweep the bottom. I guess I was looking for people's similar experiences
I have now had 2 pools with their fair share of environmental debris. I have never once brushed without something poofing somewhere. If I had algae concerns, it would be miserable to discern when the SLAM was over, and it was just back to plain old pollen/farm dust.

I would likely settle on 3 straight passing OCLTs
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.