Hey all, I couldn't find any answers to this question, though I feel like I have read about it before somewhere as a legitimate thing to do.
Background:
I use the Dichlor+bleach method to maintain my 450 gal hot tub, and so far things are all good. But a while back I overdid the Dichlor (I ran out of alternatives for logistic reasons, and needed to get something in there); I ended up with ~60ppm CYA.
Since then, I've compensated by keeping my FC on the higher side - 5-7.5ppm, as I read that CYA's chlorine-blocking is linear - 60ppm of CYA will weaken chlorine 50% compared to with 30ppm of CYA. I also have 50ppm borates, 60ppm TA and 350ppm CH.
My question is:
Is double-the-FC-to-compensate-for-double-CYA indeed a legitimate thing to do?
If so, that seems useful/convenient to do anyway for high bather load/chlorine demand - it allows you to add more chlorine, but less frequently (offgassing aside), and get effective sanitization without overchlorinating your tub or bathers.
I also want to know how far can one push this (eg: could I have 200ppm CYA with 30ppm of FC, jump right in the tub and be okay for a week without adding more bleach?). What limits how far you can go?
My guess about this:
Adding too much bleach at once would lead to some intolerable upward swing in pH. Perhaps you could offset this by combining the bleach with additional acid + additional alkalinity, and until the next bleach addition aerate as necessary to 'burn off' that extra alkalinity+acid and keep the pH in a good range. Though that sounds awkward to orchestrate and in most cases far more work that just adding less bleach more frequently.
Many thanks in advance, and thanks to all the helpful people on this forum who have got me this far in comprehending a surprisingly challenging craft!
Background:
I use the Dichlor+bleach method to maintain my 450 gal hot tub, and so far things are all good. But a while back I overdid the Dichlor (I ran out of alternatives for logistic reasons, and needed to get something in there); I ended up with ~60ppm CYA.
Since then, I've compensated by keeping my FC on the higher side - 5-7.5ppm, as I read that CYA's chlorine-blocking is linear - 60ppm of CYA will weaken chlorine 50% compared to with 30ppm of CYA. I also have 50ppm borates, 60ppm TA and 350ppm CH.
My question is:
Is double-the-FC-to-compensate-for-double-CYA indeed a legitimate thing to do?
If so, that seems useful/convenient to do anyway for high bather load/chlorine demand - it allows you to add more chlorine, but less frequently (offgassing aside), and get effective sanitization without overchlorinating your tub or bathers.
I also want to know how far can one push this (eg: could I have 200ppm CYA with 30ppm of FC, jump right in the tub and be okay for a week without adding more bleach?). What limits how far you can go?
My guess about this:
Adding too much bleach at once would lead to some intolerable upward swing in pH. Perhaps you could offset this by combining the bleach with additional acid + additional alkalinity, and until the next bleach addition aerate as necessary to 'burn off' that extra alkalinity+acid and keep the pH in a good range. Though that sounds awkward to orchestrate and in most cases far more work that just adding less bleach more frequently.
Many thanks in advance, and thanks to all the helpful people on this forum who have got me this far in comprehending a surprisingly challenging craft!
Last edited: