Exchanging water after pool opening

The iron is coming from the salt. Opened a perfectly stain free pool this year after struggling with iron stains for three years. The difference? Used Aquasalt last year with a complete water exchange. Just sayin’
+1 for Aquasalt.

My local pool store sells it for a decent price. Not as low as the big box store salt but worth it for the quality.

full
 
FC 5
pH 7.3 ( I have been keeping it at about 7)
Ta. 60
Cya 80
Salt. 3100
That’s all I usually test

I had my fill water tested through our county extension office. I had to pay for it! And, it showed no iron. I’ve had the pool for 8 years and haven’t had any problems with it. I’m blaming it on the Clorox salt. I feel like the exchange didn’t get it all. My salt read 800 ppm after the exchange. But, after balancing my FC has been between 5-6. There has been a very light yellow stain. It wasn’t really even that noticeable, unless you were looking for it. But, this happened in a week. And, the main difference was pool temperature. Could it be some sort of Algae? The water still looks clear though.
I'd like to know what your CC is because FC isn't making the mark on the chart for SWCG or chlorine. For a chlorine pool CYA 80 the minimum FC is 6 which isn't where you want to be but rather the target of 9-11 and for a SWCG pool minimum is 4 and target of 6-11. You may have simple algae as you're flirting the line for sure.
 
Would algae be that yellow orangish color? I was thinking maybe it has an algae biofilm that the iron was sticking too. I’ll check the CC and run the pool longer. The FC was actually running at about 6. And, I quit running the pump as long because I was thinking that the high chlorine levels would have an affect on the staining of the iron.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mdragger88
Do an
Overnight Chlorine Loss Test.
If you pass- test the stains with the vit C.
They may be light enough for the sequesterant to lift without having to go through the aa treatment again.
If you fail the oclt - its slam time & you can deal with any stains afterwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darin and HermanTX
It never has been iron. your available cholorine is too low. You have the water reports to prove you dont have much iron. pool/softener salt does not have that much iron. the salt you buy at the hardware store is at least 99.6% NaCl.
 
It never has been iron. your available cholorine is too low. You have the water reports to prove you dont have much iron. pool/softener salt does not have that much iron. the salt you buy at the hardware store is at least 99.6% NaCl.
Some - including myself, have accidentally introduced iron via “dirty” salt from well known trusted brands (including the one the op used after refilling since her previous aa treatment). The OP may very well still have both an iron & now an algae problem. The fc/algae issue absolutely takes priority then any possible metal staining can be investigated/dealt with after algae is removed from the equation.
She didn’t ever use a sequesterant after the Aa treatment so its not surprising that some staining might return as not all of the water was completely exchanged.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Do an
Overnight Chlorine Loss Test.
If you pass- test the stains with the vit C.
They may be light enough for the sequesterant to lift without having to go through the aa treatment again.
If you fail the oclt - its slam time & you can deal with any stains afterwards.
I’m not losing chlorine and my CC is zero. I believe it is definitely remnants from my leftover salt. I’m doing and AA treatment today and will try to sequester the rest of the season. I’ll be doing a white bucket test on ANY salt before putting it in the pool. The only other possibility is a piece of rusty equipment in my system somewhere. Praying for a good result!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mdragger88
It never has been iron. your available cholorine is too low. You have the water reports to prove you dont have much iron. pool/softener salt does not have that much iron. the salt you buy at the hardware store is at least 99.6% NaCl.
I dealt with this all last summer. I already tried slamming. It actually pushed the iron out of the water onto the walls. I’ll keep updating.
 
I’m not losing chlorine and my CC is zero. I believe it is definitely remnants from my leftover salt. I’m doing and AA treatment today and will try to sequester the rest of the season. I’ll be doing a white bucket test on ANY salt before putting it in the pool. The only other possibility is a piece of rusty equipment in my system somewhere. Praying for a good result!!
jennifer lawrence the hunger games gif GIF

I sprung for the aquasalt this year - only needed 3 or 4 bags so it wasn’t too bad. A few bucks more per bag than the diamond crystals splash ready & the mortons prof.
I have some of each of those left over from last year & will be doing the white bucket test with them soon!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude
jennifer lawrence the hunger games gif GIF

I sprung for the aquasalt this year - only needed 3 or 4 bags so it wasn’t too bad. A few bucks more per bag than the diamond crystals splash ready & the mortons prof.
I have some of each of those left over from last year & will be doing the white bucket test with them soon!
I actually can’t find the aqua salt anywhere. I used Morton prof. And, I bought the diamond crystal splash to add throughout the year. The pool looks beautiful now. It didn’t take nearly as much AA to clean it up. So, maybe it’s a good sign. Tomorrow I’ll start adding chlorine and hopefully I be able to keep it sequestered.
 
I’m not losing chlorine and my CC is zero. I believe it is definitely remnants from my leftover salt. I’m doing and AA treatment today and will try to sequester the rest of the season. I’ll be doing a white bucket test on ANY salt before putting it in the pool. The only other possibility is a piece of rusty equipment in my system somewhere. Praying for a good result!!
(ahem) Aquasalt (ahem ahem)
I actually can’t find the aqua salt anywhere. I used Morton prof. And, I bought the diamond crystal splash to add throughout the year. The pool looks beautiful now. It didn’t take nearly as much AA to clean it up. So, maybe it’s a good sign. Tomorrow I’ll start adding chlorine and hopefully I be able to keep it sequestered.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0837.png
    IMG_0837.png
    201.9 KB · Views: 6
I actually can’t find the aqua salt anywhere. I used Morton prof. And, I bought the diamond crystal splash to add throughout the year. The pool looks beautiful now. It didn’t take nearly as much AA to clean it up. So, maybe it’s a good sign. Tomorrow I’ll start adding chlorine and hopefully I be able to keep it sequestered.
Do you have the sequestrant on hand? If the stains are gone- add it now.
 
Do you have the sequestrant on hand? If the stains are gone- add it now.
I’ve added 4 bottles. I even bought the test kit to test the amount of the purple stuff in your pool. I’m working on balancing my chemicals now. It only took 3 lbs to lift the stains. So, maybe I can keep the stains away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mdragger88

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support