This much acid demand is normal....right?

DNadig

Member
Apr 13, 2024
21
Dallas, TX
New pool. This is the first season. In Texas. Approx 17,500 Gal. Chlorine. Motorized cover that stays closed when not being used. Gunite with plaster.

The pool guy who did our startup told me that our new plaster will be acid "thirsty" and as such for the first year, I will probably have to add twice as much acid as I will on following years. He also suggested that because of this, I should make my pH goal to be on the lower end of the normal range...he suggested my target pH be 7.2.

I've found that I'm adding about 1/2 gal of muriatic acid every week. This seems like a LOT of acid, but I also don't have a good reference. I check pH once a week and every time it is usually right at 8.0 or even higher. Add the 1/2 gal, and the next day the pH is usually right around 7.2.

My alkalinity has been staying at around 100 pretty stabile.

So my question is really 2 fold:

1) Is 1/2 gal per week a normal amount for a new plaster pool? I have no good reference....just seems shocking.
2) Assuming the answer to #1 above is "yes, normal", should I change my pH testing to twice a week, which will probably come out to adding 1/4 gallon every 3-4 days. I'm guessing it is better that I try to keep the pH more consistent, rather than swinging from 7.2 to 8.0 and back down to 7.2 on a weekly cycle.....or maybe I'm over thinking it and doing once a week acid add is just fine.
 
With new plaster, it will have high acid demand. In irony, the autocover reduces the pH rise. So with out, it would take more acid.

If your TA is stable, you are good. Doing it twice a week might be better. Also only lowering the pH to 7.6 will reduce the rapid rise back to 8.
 
If the fill water you use to top it off has a high TA/pH, that could be at play as well. Though, if it stays covered most of the time, I'm guessing you don't have to add a lot of fill water so the effect is likely not that strong.

For context, I have to add about a gallon of acid a week simply because our well water has a TA around 450. But our pool is uncovered 24/7.
 
Awesome Info. Thanks!
Doing it twice a week might be better. Also only lowering the pH to 7.6 will reduce the rapid rise back to 8.
Excellent. Thanks!
Though, if it stays covered most of the time, I'm guessing you don't have to add a lot of fill water so the effect is likely not that strong.
So I was very curious about this so I installed a small water meter for our auto filler. I'm able to track how many gallons the filler puts back in the pool......and from April 11 to The beginning of June, the auto filler only put in 120 gallons of tap water in....that is only a 0.6% water turnover. Rain water does not go in the pool either (or at least very very little). I could be wrong, but don't think that this would have any effect on our water pH in any true way.
 
So I was very curious about this so I installed a small water meter for our auto filler. I'm able to track how many gallons the filler puts back in the pool......and from April 11 to The beginning of June, the auto filler only put in 120 gallons of tap water in....that is only a 0.6% water turnover. Rain water does not go in the pool either (or at least very very little). I could be wrong, but don't think that this would have any effect on our water pH in any true way.
Next level tracking, right there. Nice!

Yeah, with that little water going in the effect should be minimal.
 
Unless you have a very high end water meter on the autofill, it does not pick up the very low flow usually going to the pool.
 
Unless you have a very high end water meter on the autofill, it does not pick up the very low flow usually going to the pool.
I ran into this problem and didn't want to spend the money to buy a more expensive meter. My solution was to install an irrigation valve attached to my automation with a 2 hour/ day schedule in the late evening as the sun is setting. Then, the water is refilled at once with the float fully open so sufficient flow is achieved. I am sure that as it gets close to full there may be some intermittent on/off flow as the valve settles, but it is good enough for me. Just a thought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mknauss
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.