So this is an ongoing problem now. I used the cheap flappers and they would work for a few days then might not, then work again, then I would put some lube on the flapper and it would work again maybe for a night or two. Now I broke down and bought a Jandy one and its leaking down as we speak. I know there is nothing wrong with anything else as one of the flappers held for at least a week just recently. I don't know what to do, but I"m about to lose my mind. Can anyone help?