Recommendations for new filter?

DThompson55

Member
Jun 20, 2016
21
Manchester, CT
We had a Sta-Rite III DE filter but 20 years of weather, wear and tear, finally took it out. Any recommendations on how to choose, what to watch out for, maybe which brands, where to shop? Or should I just go over to Leslie and see what they have?
 

faby3003

LifeTime Supporter
Jul 14, 2011
244
St. Paul, MN
I believe that is a similar filter to what I have. Is it the type of DE where you can take the cartridge out and hose it off (vs. having to backwash)?

What is wrong with your old filter? Did something happen to the housing, or is it just the filter media that wore out?

If you want that same type of DE filter with the removable cartridge that is easy to hose off, I think the Sta-Rite is the only option. If you're open to changing, I would get a large cartridge filter. If you were to get a 300-400 sq. ft. cartridge filter you may only have to clean it once or twice per season. I have been thinking about replacing my Sta-Rite DE filter with a Hayward Swimclear C4030 (about $800 online).
 

DThompson55

Member
Jun 20, 2016
21
Manchester, CT
Hi Faby - Yes, that is exactly the filter I have, kind of a DE Cartridge. The problem is that the housing went out of round somehow, and it's nearly impossible to fit it back together without a huge effort for two people. So after two years of complaining about it we decided to do something instead. There was really nothing wrong with the Sta-Rite, other than the last couple years. And it has lasted at least 20 years. So maybe I'll go with that again. First I'll read the Pool School - Filter Comparison Article.
 

DThompson55

Member
Jun 20, 2016
21
Manchester, CT
To complete this thread - I went with a Sta-Rite PLM100 that I purchased from InYoPool.com. It cost a little less, has twice the capacity of the PLD50, and the plumbing matches identically.
 

Other Threads of Interest