Well, just an update on this. Given the fact that my home was still under warranty, I decided to call the home warranty company and see if they'd take care of it. Well they did, and I was impressed with the turnaround. The pump went out Friday afternoon, I put in a claim Friday night and they had someone out Saturday morning. The technician tried to turn on the pump and it sparked and started smoking. He told me to leave the breaker in the off position and they'd replace it on Monday morning...which they did.
Now my question is that it looks like they replaced my Pentair Challenger 1.5hp with a Century/Centurion 1.0 hp. I've been reading that True HP can vary based on Service Factor, but just a quick check online, the Challenger goes for around $500 and the Century is around $150. Did they replace very nice pump with cheapo pump?
Upon further research, it looks like I had a Centurion pump motor before as well. Is the "Challenger" the whole pump system including baskeet, lid, impeller, etc? Sorry for the confusion.