Pool Cover Reel Opinions

[DPM20]

Hi Everyone
We have an kidney shaped pool with a solar cover (see picture). When I take the cover off a lot of dirt goes into pool which I'm sure is not good. So for that and ease, I am thinking of getting a pool cover reel.
First Question - do folks think they are worth it?
If so, my follow-on questions are:

1. Which one - From reading there are a few of them that have good reviews (not too sure what the difference is between #1 &#2 other than price?)
   1. ($149) VINGLI Pool Cover Reel Set Aluminum Solar Swimming Inground Cover Blanket Reel - Amazon.com : VINGLI Pool Cover Reel Set 18 Feet Pool Solar Cover Reel for Inground Swimming Pool, Aluminum Solar Swimming Inground Cover Blanket Reel (Upgrade) : Garden & Outdoor
   2. ($129) VINGLI Aluminum Solar Swimming Inground Pool Cover Reel - Amazon.com : VINGLI Aluminum Solar Swimming Inground Pool Cover Reel Set, Up to 18-Feet Wide x 40-Feet Length : Garden & Outdoor
   3. ($125) Nova Microdermabrasion Swimming Pool Cover Reel - Amazon.com : Nova Microdermabrasion Swimming Pool Cover Reel Set 21 FT Aluminum Inground Solar Cover Reel w/Thermometer : Garden & Outdoor
2. What size is needed? Would one of the 18' Reels work? I put dimensions on the picture (large side is 20' and small side is 15') - I would like to put on the side w/ the smaller kidney as it's out of the way
3. Where should I put it - I would like to put on the side w/ the smaller kidney as it's out of the way. And then fold the 20' end in as I roll up. Is that a problem (by maybe putting too much stress on that side)?
4. Are there any other things I should consider?

Thanks again for all of the fantastic advice!
Dave

 

[Gibby13]

@DPM20 what did you go with?