Need some advice

Re: New to the forum but have had a pool for 10 years - Need Some Advice - Thanks!

pookiesunshine - agreed. Thank you.

- - - Updated - - -

Thanks to all who have responded. And thanks everyone who seem to generally care! However, what most on this forum have failed to recognize is that I know (and have acknowledged several times) chemistry is critical and must be correct. Given that, I can/will work with local experts to get/keep the chemistry correct. So, for the purposes of this forum, I was hoping to get beyond that fact and hear from others who have had "correct chemistry" and who may have also experienced a similar issue due to excessive rain/yard run off into their pool. If you do not have experience with this exact scenario, please do not waste your time or mine to provide an opinion about chemistry. If you do, I'd love to hear what you did - in addition to making sure your chemistry was correct. LOL! :D

Your pictures and the fact that your pool is turning green after rain clearly indicates your chemistry is off, I don't care what your local experts say. Your chemistry is off, and that is a fact, or your pool would not be turning green. Also, it is impossible, yes impossible, like completely impossible, to determine if someone has been in your exact situation without looking at valid chemistry readings. Even if you found someone with a pool, and a sloping yard, and for whom it turned green after it rained, there would be no way to ascertain if their situation was remotely similar to yours without looking at chemistry levels.

I will give you this advice since it sounds like what you are looking for: put in your drains and solve your runoff problem. Then come back here if you want sanitized water in your pool. You don't have it now, and won't have it when you put drains in without dealing with the chemistry imbalance you obviously have.
 
Re: New to the forum but have had a pool for 10 years - Need Some Advice - Thanks!

Well, you have shown absolutely nothing to disprove any of our statements. You have stood there, claimed perfect chemistry, and offered no proof. So we have no reason to believe you. In fact, your reluctance to share any numbers is pretty telling of how little you trust them. Is it fear of having to accept that you don't know? Is it that you just refuse to believe the people you give money to could be frauds?

I don't know. I just know what I know about pool chemistry, and if you call any of those pictures a "crystal clear" pool then I can confidently say that I, and everyone who replied to this thread, knows a lot more about it than your team of so-called experts.

Par for the course in this industry I'm afraid, no certification required to open a pool store and start tossing out advice.
 
Re: New to the forum but have had a pool for 10 years - Need Some Advice - Thanks!

Not sure why you are so defensive. As a moderator you should be less aggressive and try to see other options/solutions just in case you may not be completely right. You should also not criticize local experts as hopefully the 150K members are someone else's local experts too.

Sorry you can't understand/imagine this happening when chemistry is good. Oh well, like they say, when all you have is a hammer, all your problems look like nails.
 
Re: New to the forum but have had a pool for 10 years - Need Some Advice - Thanks!

Not sure why you are so defensive. As a moderator you should be less aggressive and try to see other options/solutions just in case you may not be completely right. You should also not criticize local experts as hopefully the 150K members are someone else's local experts too.

Sorry you can't understand/imagine this happening when chemistry is good. Oh well, like they say, when all you have is a hammer, all your problems look like nails.

If you have someone telling you that this is possible with good water chemistry, then you need to find another someone to help you with your pool.

This is not getting defensive, people just honestly want to help you with your problem, and are trying very hard to help you understand that the problem is related to water chemistry.
 
Re: New to the forum but have had a pool for 10 years - Need Some Advice - Thanks!

Sorry you can't understand/imagine this happening when chemistry is good. Oh well, like they say, when all you have is a hammer, all your problems look like nails.
Lol, can't understand or imagine the impossible. That's us!

But what if...

Hey guys, it's time to pack it in. All those people who have come here with green pools and "perfect chemistry"? Turns out that is perfectly normal! Yeah, I know we have shown time and time again how someone's chemistry wasn't perfect and helped thousands clear their pools and get their water clearer than they had ever seen it and kept it that way, but apparently we were wrong. No, see all we have is a hammer. I don't know, some weird metaphor by the person who showed how wrong we were. Huh? Yeah their pool was green, but the chemistry was good! What? No, they didn't show any test results backing that up. What, you don't just automatically believe them? See, that's the problem we have here. We require things like "data" and "numbers to base our information on". If we are going to make it in this industry we have to stop basing things off of information and science and start recognizing that pools turn green randomly even when everything is perfect and that it has nothing to do with chlorine or CYA levels. I know, I know, I was shocked by this too, but they put forward such a good argument that I really think there is no possible recourse. I mean, did you see the hammer metaphor?

Well, I know once we shut down I'm going to retire somewhere in the Bahamas. Put a bunch of money down on a beautiful villa, sight unseen. Realtor told me it was perfect so I wrote the check on the spot. Well not actually a check, they required cash for some weird reason, but I'm pumped!


Hmmmm, nah. Think I will stick with the possible and leave the impossible to the pool store experts.
 
Re: New to the forum but have had a pool for 10 years - Need Some Advice - Thanks!

You stated you test every day and have the pool store "check you" ... why still no test results?
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.