Is my Hayward T Cell T-15 dead?

Needsdecaf

Well-known member
Jun 28, 2014
213
The Woodlands, TX
Before anyone comments: yes I know I need to get accurate test strips. Can anyone recommend a brand?

The facts: I have a Hayward T Cell T-15 on my pool. It’s approx 10.5 years. Living in Houston it sees use nearly year round.

It’s oversized for my roughly 8,500 gallon pool. My builder told me “better to be oversized and work less hard, it’ll last longer”. No idea if that’s true or not because I wasn’t on here at the time however it’s done well over the years.

This last season I’ve been having trouble with erratic readings. The salt level would fluctuate between where I keep it in the high 2xxx to low 3xxx range down to “low” under 2200 or even lower. I’ve tried to give it the acid bath and cleaning as they call for and it would pick back up. I usually keep my SWG set around 35-40% in order to not blast the pool (remember oversized) unless it’s really hot but I was starting to get sporadic algae outbreaks.

At the end of the season, I couldn’t get the thing to read above low and make chlorine, so my pool is now green. I’ve tested with my strips but either I have a bad batch, I don’t know how to read, or a poor design because I can’t seem to get a true reading on what the salt level is. Just before it got cold it was reading in the 800 range on the controller! I did add one bag of salt because I knew it was low from the rain, and it didn’t change. Then it jumped up to 2700 and this morning it’s reading 3200 so something is off.


Is it just time for a new cell? Have I gotten my money’s worth?
Replace with a more reasonable sized cell? Would be nice to stick with that brand and simply unscrew, re-screw and plug in.

Any other thoughts appreciated. And tips on good, easy to read, test strips are welcome!
 
Before anyone comments: yes I know I need to get accurate test strips. Can anyone recommend a brand?
Get a test kit...recommendations here...Link-->Test Kits Compared

Get one with a salt test kit. You should test for salt with the salt drop kit and not rely on the cell.

10.5 years in TX is a long run.

Yes, it is time for a new cell. You absolutely got your money's worth.

Personally, I stay on brand, screw it on and plug it in. You'd probably be ok with T-3, but I suspect the reason you got to 10 years is because of the oversized cell...I'd get the T-15.
 
Get a test kit...recommendations here...Link-->Test Kits Compared

Get one with a salt test kit. You should test for salt with the salt drop kit and not rely on the cell.

10.5 years in TX is a long run.

Yes, it is time for a new cell. You absolutely got your money's worth.

Personally, I stay on brand, screw it on and plug it in. You'd probably be ok with T-3, but I suspect the reason you got to 10 years is because of the oversized cell...I'd get the T-15.
I have a TFP test kit. It did not come with salt strips. Had it many years and I have been refreshing the reagents.

Just need salt strip recommendations.

Edit, I seethe salt / ph meter. Probably will go ahead and grab that. The heck with strips, lol. We get a lot of rain here.
 
Get a test kit...recommendations here...Link-->Test Kits Compared

Get one with a salt test kit. You should test for salt with the salt drop kit and not rely on the cell.

10.5 years in TX is a long run.

Yes, it is time for a new cell. You absolutely got your money's worth.

Personally, I stay on brand, screw it on and plug it in. You'd probably be ok with T-3, but I suspect the reason you got to 10 years is because of the oversized cell...I'd get the T-15.
Unless the OP has software revision 1.50 or higher, unit won't work with a T-3, possibly only a T-15. Average life of an OEM T-15 running 100% is 9000 hours +/-.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PoolStored
You'd probably be ok with T-3, but I suspect the reason you got to 10 years is because of the oversized cell...I'd get the T-15.
If you want to change cell size, check what cell types the controller can be changed to. Older controllers only supported T-5 or T-15.
 
I agree with all thoughts above. If you want and it’s possible based on your software revision, you can select a smaller cell size in the controller software and use the one you have…..you may be able squeeze a little more life out of the current cell. You’d have to adjust the production up if you do this. It’s a bandaid but could give you some production as you’re acquiring a replacement cell.
 
Amazon pricing
T-3 makes .5lb/day = 33FC in your pool at 100%. Assume it works for 10,000 hours, or 416 days. That is 13,750FC. Price is 490. So $.036 per FC.
T-15 makes 15lb/day = 92FC in your pool at 100%. Assume it works for 10,000 hours, or 416 days. That is 38,272FC. Price is 690. So $.018per FC.

You can change the assumption on the hours, the ratio of the cost per FC will still be that T-15 will cost 50% less per FC than the T-3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Needsdecaf

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
How do you convert lbs of chlorine to FC?

For reference I run my vs pump three times a day. Once for 90 minutes in the morning at speed 2, 60 minutes at mid day at speed 4 and 60 minutes in the evening at speed 3. All with the SWG at 35-45% depending on how hot it is.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.