Heater bolts corroding

I doubt your heater was killed by bad water chemistry unless you used Trichlor tablets in a feeder.

I suspect corrosive condensation from cold weather operation did it.


My prediction is if you install another MasterTemp heater and run it the same way it too will leak in about 4 years.
How long does that normally take? A few years ago in the Texas freeze my heater was accidentally on for a few days. I was debugging a HLS error and saw my bolts are all rusted on the manifold. Trying to figure out what happened.
 
There isn’t a check valve between ic40 and the heater. Could that be an issue? It really looks like corrosion from chlorine to me. But I don’t know how it could be outside the manifold.

The bolts are toast. I am going to have to drill them out likely. So not trying to remove unless I am trying to replace the whole bottom manifold and heater core. I have never seen water leaking in that spot.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Any risk to waiting for it to fail by leaking without the bolts removed? Or should I be proactive in fixing it?

I would still like to understand what is happening that caused it. I try to keep ph in check it always goes to 8 and then I dose with acid to about 7.4. My chlorine levels have been running a bit high but my cya is usually 50-60. By high I mean 7-8. Still getting use to the pool and ic40 runtime percentages. I will check everything this weekend.
 
The blower pushes the air/gas mixture into the flame holder and the heat goes through the heat exchanger.

If the heat exchanger is leaking, then the insulation is getting wet and the tub is rusting out pretty fast.

Note that the bottom picture is From a Jandy Heater, but the design is the same.

1726850518576.png

1726850591807.png
 
Maybe excessive flow if you run the pump at full speed.

Maybe the heater ran with no flow?

Maybe an electrical problem causing excessive corrosion.

I don't see any obvious errors that would cause a problem or point to a diagnosis.
 
I didn't see any water coming out of the bottom hole. I tried one further up (that still could be turned) and didn't see water there either. I was running in pool mode which is a slower RPM (2200) vs spa mode. Maybe my spa mode is turned up too high? I did have it set near max (3100) trying to deal with an issue at one point. Maybe that's what caused the issue. I will have to see what the recommended speed is in the manual. Plus maybe watch the bolts with it set to spa mode and no heat.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.