Make sure you are testing CYA properly:
Do test at midday or near abouts with sun behind you. Pour solution to one line then GLANCE into the tube. You can start by pouring to a line that is well over what you expect.
When you see the dot at a GLANCE, pour to the next line. Glance in. Still see dot easily? Pour to next line.
When the dot is not visible at a lightning quick glance, that is your CYA. There may be a slight whisper of the dot, but you can call it there. If you stare into the tube, your mind will fill in that dot. Hence my all-caps GLANCE.
From this point on, when you do test CYA, do it under the same conditions. If you vary the time of day, or do when it is cloudy, you are going to have different results.