Choosing a heater for the Southeast

kmmattson

Active member
Jul 6, 2020
27
Beaufort, SC
Hi, I'm reading up on all the options for pool heaters. We live in coastal South Carolina (almost Savannah, GA which is similar climate to N FL since we're very near the water on an island...right now during summer we have temps in upper 80's-mid 90's during the day, low 80's to upper 70's at night. In winter, we can still get days in the low 70's and usually have a few freezes per year although this past winter we didn't have any and a few years ago we had several days in a row in the 20's). We installed an above ground pool this summer and want to extend our swimming season - it's already cold in the pool as we've had some cloudy days/rain and night temps in the mid-70's! I think we're unlikely to use it much when the water temp dips below 80 (ok, we are huge wimps!! It's the Florida blood). It seems like we're resigned not to use the pool Nov-Feb because it just won't be warm enough air to want to swim (we have a hot tub too) but it would be great to be able to use it some on nice sunny days Mar-Apr and Sept-Oct when the water temp will dip.

We're unlikely to use the solar option - too much space needed for the panels and the pool isn't close to the house. I also don't love the idea of the solar blanket - we've got young children that can swim and of course we keep the exterior pool ladder inaccessible but I worry if they somehow climbed something and fell onto a pool cover that they would get tangled and be unable to get out. Nor do we have anywhere to store something that bulky and we tend to be in and out of the pool so I think putting it on and off would not happen. We do have gas lines so that's an option. I don't want to spend a few hundred dollars each month to heat the pool either...

So anyway...#1, why is the water already so cold? Is it to be expected to have a small pool change temps easily? Would it improve temp to run/not run the pump at certain times? Anything else we can do to keep the water warmer when it's not just hot and sunny other than the solar blanket?

And does anyone have a suggestion as to our best options for a heater? Say in those outside months, we only use the pool 1-2x per week. In that case, would a gas heater that could quickly bring our small pool temp up be the way to go? What if we want to be able to swim at any time? And what about in summer months when we are just being wimps? How much are we likely to need to run a heater to keep the temp above 80? I'm looking specifically for recommendations for our climate which is relatively mild and humid most of the year.
 
Living so far south, you should have no problems with cold water in August. Is the pool in the shade most of the day? It could just be the small size of your pool not retaining heat as much during days without intense sun/heat. SOLAR COVER will solve your problems of cold water in summer.

If you do not need to heat your pool all the time in spring/fall and just want to heat it for random warm days, a gas heater is what you need. A heat pump will be running a lot and is better for maintaining a temp. A gas heater will heat the water much faster and you can run it when air temps fall below 55. An above ground pool will also not have the same insulation on the sides as an in ground so you will also lose a lot of heat through the walls. I am sure even in February you will get warm snaps into the 70's so a gas heater could heat it up quickly to use as a big hot tub just for the day.

Start with the solar cover because you will also lose a lot of heat generated by a gas heater when you heat during spring/fall.
 
Thanks for the recommendation...I am going to head over to amazon and get a solar cover today. I do think it’s just the small size of the pool - it’s in almost full sun but for the last week the weather has been predominately cloudy during the day and dipping to mid 70s at night. I guess it is just having trouble getting warm. I was also able to find a great heater calculator on the Hayward website and given our electric/gas costs it turns out it is WAY cheaper, even if we wanted to KEEP the pool at a certain temp and not just spot heat, to do gas.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.