First off apologies for my bad artwork. But this roughly my pool, pump is a 1.5hp single speed Hayward Superpump.

When I have the pool set to take water in from the main drain or the skimmer my pressure on the filter reads 16psi, when I switch it to take in water both the main drain and the skimmer at the same time, the pressure jumps to about 25psi.
This is something my mother and I don't remember happening in the past. The only difference is the unused return jet. It use to be for an old Arneson pool sweep, but would act as a somewhat normal return jet without it running. At some point after the pool sweep failed the line was plugged and separated on the filter side.
I am wondering if getting the unused line hooked up again would bring the pressure down when using both the main drain and skimmer together, or is this pump too strong for the pool? I see a lot of people with similar pools using 3/4hp or 1hp pumps.
Thanks for any help.

When I have the pool set to take water in from the main drain or the skimmer my pressure on the filter reads 16psi, when I switch it to take in water both the main drain and the skimmer at the same time, the pressure jumps to about 25psi.
This is something my mother and I don't remember happening in the past. The only difference is the unused return jet. It use to be for an old Arneson pool sweep, but would act as a somewhat normal return jet without it running. At some point after the pool sweep failed the line was plugged and separated on the filter side.
I am wondering if getting the unused line hooked up again would bring the pressure down when using both the main drain and skimmer together, or is this pump too strong for the pool? I see a lot of people with similar pools using 3/4hp or 1hp pumps.
Thanks for any help.