Maybe my buried tank idea is not so bonkers after all...
- An underground 250 gal polyethylene tank with a riser runs ~$500:
http://www.plastic-mart.com/product/6901/250-gallon-underground-water-cistern-storage-tank-43746
- A 7 GPM chlorine-resistant transfer pump/siphon runs ~$22:
http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200622833_200622833
- Digging a ~4' wide by 7' deep hole to bury the tank next to my pad? (I don't know, but let's say $500).
- Stenner single speed 100 psi pump with tubing runs ~$250:
http://www.lockewell.com/index.php?...ducts_id=149&gclid=CMun55zf6McCFcsXHwod2n0BZQ
Total: $1275 plus chlorine ($~600/season):
http://chemdirectusa.com/SodiumHypochlorite-55gallon-1.aspx
OK. It's not a cheap solution, but I could do one "fill up" for the season with 2, 55-gal drums of 12.5% diluted to 6.25% and maintained at below-ground temp that would probably average 60-70° F. That would make temp-based degradation manageable.
Pros:
- Liquid chlorine addition in the spirit of TFPC: no pucks, no pool store schmucks.
- No risk of spilling an above ground tank with risk to kids/pets
- No schlepping bleach daily/weekly/monthly: can likely leave the pool for a few days at a time once dialed in.
- Stenner probably more reliable than a SWG (I could be wrong about this, but I'm a newbie).
- Fewer issues with pH creep as reported with SWGs.
- Pump run times/flow are not an issue: Cl can be added regardless of pump speed (I'm hoping to run a VS pump on low speed 18-20 hr/day and on higher speed 4-6 hr/day).
Cons:
- Upfront cost is equivalent to a SWG
- Operating costs (~$600 for bleach/season) are higher than SWG even considering cell replacement, etc.
- Tank could leak (seems unlikely), but no real environmental risk if it does. People put bleach down their wells frequently.
- Finding a source for 55 gal drums of 12.5% bleach (seems solvable, especially if chemdirect or another supplier pans out). Cheaper solutions seem likely. I'm still waiting to hear back from Buckmans (not expecting much, but why not try?). I have a poker buddy who works for our local water treatment company...they use tons of hypochlorite. Basically, I'm an optimist at heart.
OK. I'm guessing this idea will still sound full-on bonkers to most. I'm just tossing a newbie, maverick idea out there. Thoughts? Comments? Where has my thinking gone astray?
Cheers,
Jay
PS. Just occurred to me that maybe this has already been done and I'm not aware of it. Apologies for my ignorance if that is the case.