Trust the Taylor test or the IC40 reading?

SpockF4

Member
Apr 30, 2023
17
Orlando FL
Pool Size
10000
Surface
Plaster
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
SWG Type
Pentair Intellichlor IC-40
Hello all
I just completed a complete overhaul of my pool. About 10k gallon plaster pool that I had resurfaced with pebble tec. All new equipment which includes:
Pentair intellicenter i5PS
Pentair IC40 SWG
Pentair CC150 Cartridge Filter
Pentair Superflo 2.2HP VSP

I followed all the recommendations for the new pebble surface as in daily brushing and just using liquid chlorine to maintain the chemistry for the first month. I am now at about the six week mark and I am ready to start up the SWG. I should add that this is my first time working with a salt pool so I know nothing except what I have tried to read up on! The pool chemistry, using a Taylor test kit is as follows:
FC=4
CC=0
PH=7.9
TA=90
CH=260
CYA=34 (A bit low but deathly afraid of overshooting!)
Salt=3400

My question: When I energized the IC40 for the first time (about 10 minutes ago) it came back with a salt reading of 2800. Of course this is telling me I have a low salt condition as Pentair recommends 3600. Now I tend to think that the Taylor test result of 3400 is way more accurate than the onboard IC40 result of 2800. How do I proceed going forward? Add a bit more salt? I added 40lb bags of salt, one at a time, and tested after 24 hours with each bag to determine how much one 40lb bag would raise the salt ppm. Turns out each bag raised it by 600ppm, according to the Taylor test. Water temp is about 79 degrees. Why is there such a large divergence in the two salt readings? I really don’t want to over shoot the salt content but I do want the IC40 to be happier. How should I proceed? Will the two salt readings get closer together over time, as in does a brand new IC40 need a “break in period” to get better salt readings?
Again, newbie at this salt water stuff and any and all help is appreciated!
Thanks for your time.
 
Trust your test kit. Make the cell happy.
Add 400 in salt, that will get your cell into the low end of the range for your cell (3200) and an actual value of 3800. Both completely in range.
Use your test kit to know your actual salt level and confirm how much to actually add.
Maintain 3800 for now and see what happens over time.
 
Your IC40 should have the CELL light GREEN and be generating with salt at 2800.

Give it more time for the salt to dissolve and circulate in your pool.

While Pentair recommends 3600 the cell works fine anywhere from 2800 and up. Lower salt levels are a bit better for the longevity of the electronics. I like to run my Intellichlor around 3200.
 
Trust your test kit. Make the cell happy.
Add 400 in salt, that will get your cell into the low end of the range for your cell (3200) and an actual value of 3800. Both completely in range.
The cell should be happy with 2800.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PoolStored
Ok everyone thanks for the help! I’ll stick with the Taylor results. The cell itself is showing all green lights as it should. The app is telling me low salt so I’ll just disregard that. Thanks again for the help. Much appreciated