Portable water softeners

tcat

Silver Supporter
May 30, 2012
1,784
Austin, TX
Pool Size
17000
Surface
Plaster
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
SWG Type
CircuPool Edge-40
My CH seems to always be around 500-600. My fill water is around 250 (Austin Texas). My SWG cell seems to love calcium build up, requiring 2 or 3 cleanings per season, killing its life. Would something like this be effective on auto-fill line? This says "16,000 gallons" (which is about my pool size). With Texas evaporation, that might be 3 years worth. Not sure how these things work, but seems like a low cost solution. I always keep my CSI between 0 and -.15

 
That is 16000 GRAINS. With a CH of 250 ppm, your Grains per Gallon are around 18. So you can soften about 800 or so gallons with one recharge.

That is the size of water softener I have. I recharge every 700 gallons, give or take. My fill water CH is 250 ppm.

In the summer, I have to recharge every 10-12 days.
 
There are a few of us here that use portable RV softeners. See the link in my sig...

The downside is they require frequent manual regeneration (flushing). How often depends on the size of the unit and the CH level in your fill water.

Consider a whole home water softener or maybe a dedicated automatic softener for the pool. Cost for a smaller automatic unit is about the same as the larger RV softeners. You would need access to the fill line, power for the unit, and a drain leading to the sewer for the discharge.
 
I just watched a video on recharging, looks easy enough. Can pool salt be used? Here's a photo of my auto-fill. Not sure why it's so complicated! Can I just remove all that and just feed the tank from the spigot to the pool line? The pool is well below, so no way there would be backflow.
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20241119_162808677.jpg
    PXL_20241119_162808677.jpg
    585.4 KB · Views: 12
You could set it up on your fill line. You just want to make it easy to remove and service when it needs regeneration.

Question - what is the FC and CC of your municipal water supply?
 
Don't think
You could set it up on your fill line. You just want to make it easy to remove and service when it needs regeneration.

Question - what is the FC and CC of your municipal water supply?
I've never tested FC of supply. I'm guessing zero.
 
Don't think

I've never tested FC of supply. I'm guessing zero.

Unlikely. Most municipalities supply water with a mixture of FC and CC. Typically one will see an FC level at or below 0.6ppm and a CC level at or above 1.0ppm. The EPA allows for 1 to 4ppm of total chlorine in drinking water. The FC is used as a fast sanitizer and oxidizer at the beginning point of distribution and the CC (usually monochloramine) as a long haul sanitizer to keep bacteria from growing in the distribution network.
 
I actually use pool salt to regenerate mine. It must be somewhat fine.

I also put a powered valve on mine so it only runs a time I schedule in my automation. I use a flow meter to keep track of water thru put and it does not work at the autofill dribble rate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rancho Cost-a-Lotta
From a test report from our local utility. Chloramines: 2.32. I'm sure it varies by neighborhood.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20241119-142115.png
    Screenshot_20241119-142115.png
    232.6 KB · Views: 3

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
You can just test your local water source at the mainline going into the home. There’s usually a spigot or, if you have an outdoor spigot nearby the main, let that run for a few minutes and then test the water. That will tell you what the incoming FC/CC is.

The reason why I asked and why it is important is because water softener resins are specified according to how much cross-linking they have. The higher the cross linking, the more resistant resins are to oxidation damage. If your incoming water has high total chlorine then you should really neutralize the chlorine prior to softening to avoid damage to the resin. As the resin ages and gets oxidized, its softening capacity decreases. Also, if your municipal supply has iron in it, that can be troublesome too as iron will react with the resin and lock itself into the resin structure thereby reducing softening capacity. Iron contamination can not be removed by regeneration as it typically requires an acidic soak to displace the iron. People that do high quality softener installations will often prefilter the water using a granular activated charcoal (GAC) filter to remove chlorine and metals. GAC filters are one-and-done type filters that can’t be regenerated and so they need to be changed annually. Normally you’d want a sediment filter (municipal water is often very dirty), then a GAC filter, and then a mineral softener so that the system can be operated for a long time.

Up to you on how complex you want to make it. I’d look for an RV filter that can be taken apart so that if the ion exchange resin needs changing you can do that yourself without having to throw away a perfectly good resin tank. You can often by softener resins more cheaply by the 40lbs sack so that you can refill the resin bed as-needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tcat
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.