Pool tastes salty after switching from liquid chlorine to tabs

but after switching to the tabs my water tastes much more salty.
How much time after switching did you first notice the saltier taste?

A day, week, month, year, 10 years?

Also, taste is subjective and many different things can cause a "Taste".

Salt "taste" comes from the sodium ions, not the chloride ions.

Sodium ions enter sodium channels and this registers as a salty taste.

Even though trichlor does not contain sodium, you do have to add sodium carbonate, sodium bicarbonate or sodium tetraborate to compensate for the acidity of the tabs, so you end up adding just as much sodium as other forms of chlorine.

If you are talking about salinity, you really need to have objective data like actual salinity readings from a K-1766 salt test kit and a good digital conductivity meter set to salt (Not TDS).
 
  • Like
Reactions: mgtfp
MECHANISMS OF SALT TASTE

Sodium chloride—once dissociated into ions (individual atoms that carry an electrical charge)—imparts salt taste.

It is now widely accepted that it is the sodium ion (Na+) that is primarily responsible for saltiness, although the chloride ion (Cl−) plays a modulatory role (Bartoshuk, 1980).

For example, as the negatively charged ion (anion) increases in size (e.g., from chloride to acetate or gluconate), the saltiness declines.

Many sodium compounds are not only salty but also bitter; with some anions, the bitterness predominates to such a degree that all saltiness disappears (Murphy et al., 1981).

It is believed that there are two or more types of receptors in the oral cavity, primarily on the tongue, that are responsible for triggering salt tastes (Bachmanov and Beauchamp, 2007), but major gaps in the understanding of salt taste reception remain.

The most prominent hypothesis, which has been demonstrated in mice and rats, is that one set of receptors playing a role in salt taste perception involves ion channels or pores (Epithelial sodium [Na] Channels: ENaCs).

ENaCs allow primarily sodium (and lithium) to move from outside the taste receptor cell, where it has been dissolved in saliva, into the taste cell.

The resulting increase in Na+ inside the taste cell causes the release of neurotransmitters that eventually signal salt taste to the brain (Chandrashekar et al., 2010; McCaughey, 2007; McCaughey and Scott, 1998) (Figure 3-4).

Because sodium and lithium are the only ions known to produce a purely salt taste, it is believed that these sodium- and lithium-specific channel receptors play a major role in sensing saltiness (Beauchamp and Stein, 2008; McCaughey, 2007).

 
  • Like
Reactions: mgtfp
Good stuff, thanks for that, @JamesW!

Other ions like lithium, potassium etc. can also have a taste and they might be more noticeable than sodium ions.

There is a "salt reduced" version of Australia's favourite breakfast spread, Vegemite. They have basically replaced some of the sodium chloride with potassium chloride. That made me believe that it's the chloride that's responsible for the salty taste. Much appreciate your background information on that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamesW
Taste properties of divalent salts are complex.

The first study examined the taste profiles of calcium chloride, magnesium chloride and magnesium sulfate.

These divalent cation salts were characterized primarily by bitter taste, with additional sensations described as salty, metallic, astringent, sour and sweet, generally in decreasing order of intensity.

 
Hi, I am a new pool owner with a magnapool. Why does it have a strange taste?

Yes many users often notice a metallic or bitter taste when first using MagnaPool.

This can be due to the mineral levels being quite high when first being commissioned.

It only happens when mineral level is high and often is more pronounced if pH is high.

In all instances the taste fades over the course of a few weeks as your body acclimates to the minerals content.

 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.