The first problem- oto test being dark- isn’t actually a problem, that’s a sign you actually have enough chlorine in the pool since for your cya you want 11-13ppm - which will show up dark on that test.
Your oto test should Always read darker than the highest value because 5ppm is not high enough for you.
As mentioned previously don’t make adjustments based on the oto test.
Use fas/dpd for accuracy.
For the ph you just use the highest readable measurement on the comparator block & put that number in
PoolMath as your “current” then 7.5 or 7.6 (mid 7’s) as your target.
Add the amount of acid it tells you & test again in 30 minutes or so to confirm it’s in the 7’s, if not repeat the process.
Note* when fc is above 10ppm it skews the ph test (often showing as falsely higher) so in your current situation (needing fc to be above 10ppm most all the time due to high cya) it is best if you test ph & adjust it before adding chlorine. This is one of the reasons it is impractical to have such a high cya.