Manual vac vs robot

poolboyK

Well-known member
May 19, 2024
49
Hempstead, NY
Hi, new pool user here; inherited the pool from previous owner about 3 years ago. The liner does seem to have wearing and fading. Had repaired one small knwe tear with a patch. Filter is a DE filter.

My pool is poorly located near a bunch of landscaping and dirt, as well as trees that deposit small items and fine dirt in the deep end.

I know how to manual vac to waste and it works well, but my concern is it drains a lot of water and usually requires adding 5-6 hours of water through a garden hose (either filled to top or after vacuuming) to get back to mid skimmer level. Does adding the water ruin chemistry and waste water $$$$?

On the other hand, I'm open to a robot in the $500-600 range, but am worried about potential tears or ripping in the liner. The pool also has a slope going from shallow 3.5 to 8.5 deep, Grecian pool shape.

Any advice on what the best route forward would be? Just continue manual vac and balancing? Is it really as wasteful as I think?
 

Attachments

  • C773866A-5FFB-4E66-BE3A-71A7EDEFA991.jpeg
    C773866A-5FFB-4E66-BE3A-71A7EDEFA991.jpeg
    814.8 KB · Views: 4
  • 7BDDC456-1AA6-4F45-B63A-BC3615654BD1.jpeg
    7BDDC456-1AA6-4F45-B63A-BC3615654BD1.jpeg
    849 KB · Views: 4
Hi, new pool user here; inherited the pool from previous owner about 3 years ago. The liner does seem to have wearing and fading. Had repaired one small knwe tear with a patch. Filter is a DE filter.

My pool is poorly located near a bunch of landscaping and dirt, as well as trees that deposit small items and fine dirt in the deep end.

I know how to manual vac to waste and it works well, but my concern is it drains a lot of water and usually requires adding 5-6 hours of water through a garden hose (either filled to top or after vacuuming) to get back to mid skimmer level. Does adding the water ruin chemistry and waste water $$$$?

On the other hand, I'm open to a robot in the $500-600 range, but am worried about potential tears or ripping in the liner. The pool also has a slope going from shallow 3.5 to 8.5 deep, Grecian pool shape.

Any advice on what the best route forward would be? Just continue manual vac and balancing? Is it really as wasteful as I think?
There are robots close to that price range (I use one) and I never manually vacuum. 6 hours of hose water does sound like quite a lot.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.