Is paint making my pool cloudy?

Apr 24, 2025
7
Grand Rapids, MI
IMG_16611-ezgif.com-resize.gifIMG_1653.jpg

New to pool ownership, first time opening. It's a very old concrete pool with an epoxy-based paint approx. 9 years old. When I opened the pool it was a deep green. I have been following the SLAM method for 10 days now with daily backwashing and brushing and can't improve the cloudy water. I decided to replace the filter sand on day 7, so it's been 60 hours of 24/7 filtering with new sand and constant brushing and no improvement. Frustrated with the cloudiness I decided to partially drain and refill the pool this morning. When I rub my hand on the pool wall a milky white substance comes off (feels a bit slimy). I talked to the former owner's pool guy on the phone and he says it sounds like calcium build-up and needs an acid wash. We're wondering if it's actually the paint due to its advanced age and/or improper water chemistry. I have a K2006 test kit. The readings today were:

FC - 13ppm (have been maintaining at 16ppm)
CC - 1.5ppm (has been under 0.5ppm for several days, but we had a storm last night lots of debris in water this morning)
TA - 90ppm
CH - 200ppm
pH was high before starting SLAM, but I added the poolmath suggested amount of muriatic acid
CYA - 40ppm (last tested about a week ago)

Pool Math says CH is low, am I experiencing chalking paint? Any help is appreciated!
 
Not really. Pool paint is a terrible surface material. It’s usually done as a last resort by a homeowner to make the pool look reasonable. Pool paint doesn’t hold up for more than two seasons or so and the it starts to breakdown. If you’re able to SAFELY DRAIN the pool you can power wash the old paint, maybe scrape it all down to the concrete and then repaint. But short of that, it will just keep shedding.

Replastering the pool is the only long term fix and given its age and poor condition you should make sure the pool surface is chiseled or blasted down to the gunite shell, inspect for cracks or leaks and then have a fresh coat of full-thickness plaster applied … no skim coats!