Hmmm... good suggestion. I can see how one model might have different length trips vs. another model. I'm pretty sure these are original. However, that makes me wonder if they're worn after years of daily "tripping". The pool is original to the house, which was built in 1996, and I am about 99.999999483% sure that the timer is just as original. I'll run over to Ace hardware and see if they have anything similar (I imagine they would for water heaters as well as pool pumps).
Thanks, Sarge!
[center:37ok48bn]========================= UPDATE =========================[/center:37ok48bn]
MSgtDan was right - new trips from Ace hardware - $3.49 + tax. Not bad at all! :-D
SOLUTION - For anyone searching for this issue like I was, here's what it was specifically in my case: For the extremely common T-100 series of Intermatic timers (mine's a T-104), there are specific trips that are used. When you get a set from Ace hardware (and presumably any other hardware store), they mention this fact.
The "OFF" trips are gold colored and work for all Intermatic timers, but there are two types of "ON" trips - silver and green:
(
the "green" is actually a green tinted/anodized silver and it's hard to make out at the top right, in this image)
The T-100 series requires the green trip, while their other series of timers require the silver one. I swapped out the silver I had on there for the new green one and, PRESTO! Fixed.
In looking back mentally I vaguely recall messing with the trips a year or more ago, and I seem to recall that there was at one time a green one (which I didn't see anywhere out there lately, so I must've lost or misplaced it somewhere), and that there was an "extra" trip lying around inside the timer box for some reason. At some point I may have taken the trips off and mucked about with the timer for some reason and replaced the proper green one with the improper silver one (and then promptly lost track of the green one). Only thing I can think of. Plus, like I say, I seem to recall a green one at some point... pretty Darn sure of it now.
AAAAAAaaaaaaaaaanyway...
...it's fixed. GREAT TIP, Sarge!!! Thanks!
