Dave,
I'm pretty sure that no one here is telling you that you have to use a Robot.. It appears to me that about 98% of the people that have used a Robot love them.. That leaves the other 2% that did not. It is clear that we are not going to convince you that they are better, and it is just as clear that you are not going to be able to convince the other 98% that they are wrong.
There is no right or wrong answer here. I say use whatever works for you.. and I'll use what works best for me... That way we can both be happy..
Thanks for a view from the other side.
Jim R.
I prefaced my position by saying I'm going to be the contrarian here.
Isn't thats what's cool about forums - that you get to hear from all sides?
In a robot-heavy forum, you aren't the other side, I am.
I don't intervene when guys that start threads between themselves about how great they are - I may ask questions when a guy buys a new model, but I dont rain on anyone's party - but when I guy asks a comparative question it's fair game to discuss.
I've owned both as well. I had bad experiences with them, so do my friends.
I find them expensive to buy and expensive to run over a ten-year cycle, with no better result than I get from a suction side.
I'm not trying to convince anyone they are wrong, simply add my experience alongside as a counterpoint in a thread that asks the questions.
Guys make statements here all the time about preferences as though they are universal truths when the reality is that it isn't so cut and dried - and what may be a "feature" to one isn't to another.
Like - "I'm so happy I can run my cleaner without my pump." I run a pump 12 hours a day anyway that isn't a benny to me.
In the winter, we get all kinds of wind and debris influx and I can leave a suction side in the pool for 2-3 months straight where with a robot I have to put in, take out and clean repeatedly to me is a very real downside.
Id rather backflush a big filter once than clean a robot filter every 3-4 days.
You can find all kinds of problems here with robots, cords tangling, main drain stalling, worn out tracks, gears, circuit boards, etc..
I also run a sand filter with zeo (absolutely no problems) so there are lots of places where the TFP majority and I diverge.
UD