First Post - Chlorine Question

Dave_NJ

Silver Supporter
Aug 15, 2019
112
North NJ
Pool Size
24000
Surface
Vinyl
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
SWG Type
CircuPool RJ-60 Plus
First and foremost, this forum has been very helpful in helping me understand chemical balance and how to properly maintain a pool. Many thanks to all the people who take time to answer questions and contribute!

I purchased a home with a pool about three years ago. This is my first pool and I went into it with no knowledge at all about proper maintenance. Through sheer luck I haven't had any issues these past few years even though I have been maintaining the pool myself. Recently I decided to educate myself on how to properly treat the water and equipment which is how I came to this forum. After purchasing a Taylor K-2006 test kit I ran all of the tests and everything looked great except for extremely high CYA levels. The dot disappeared well before reaching the 100 mark on the tube, after diluting and testing a few times I figured I was in the high 200-low 300 range. I have been partially draining and refilling the pool over the past few weeks (I don't have the time to do it all at once unfortunately) and I'm now around 90ppm CYA. I will continue to drain/fill until I'm around 50ppm which should be in the next week or two.

I switched from trichloro pucks to Home Depot liquid chlorine (10%) to avoid elevated CYA levels and my question is how many gallons of bleach should I expect to add per day to maintain proper FC? When I was using pucks I just put 4 in the chemical feeder and that was lasting for about a week, using LC it seems like I will need to add a gallon a day or so, is that typical? I guess I didn't think about chlorine consumption when I changed over to LC, if I run through 7 gallons a week on average that's a lot of chlorine bottles!

Test results as of last night:

FC 2.0 (shocked pool with Cal Hypo to bring up FC, will check again this evening and add LC as needed)
CC .2
TA 90
pH 7.6
CH 250
CYA 90
Temp 80 deg. F

I will try to run the overnight chlorine demand test tonight as well to check if I have any organics consuming chlorine. Pool isn't used a lot, maybe once on the weekend, and I scrub the walls at least once a week usually twice a week and the pool robot runs every day.

Thanks in advance for any comments or suggestions, it's greatly appreciated!

-Dave
 
Dave, welcome! :wave: As a general rule, we don't like to see pools use more than 4ppm of FC in 24 hrs unless there was a known heavy load (i.e. party). Using the PoolMath tool, I see that just under one gallon of 10% should increase your FC 4 ppm. Depending on your water temp and weather (i.e. cloudy sky) you may not use 4 ppm of FC per day, but that should give you a pallpark estimate. Hope that helps.
 
Dave, welcome! :wave: As a general rule, we don't like to see pools use more than 4ppm of FC in 24 hrs unless there was a known heavy load (i.e. party). Using the PoolMath tool, I see that just under one gallon of 10% should increase your FC 4 ppm. Depending on your water temp and weather (i.e. cloudy sky) you may not use 4 ppm of FC per day, but that should give you a pallpark estimate. Hope that helps.

Good to know, thanks! I have the poolmath calculator bookmarked and came up with the same numbers you did, I just wasn't sure what the usual chlorine consumption was so I appreciate the info.

You will lose between 2-4 PPM of chlorine per day. Plan on adding that every day.

Okay, looks like I will start searching for a local supplier that offers LC in 5 gal. jugs or larger. Tossing a bottle in the recycle bin every day or every other day seems like a lot of waste...
 
Or potentially adding a salt water chlorine generator (SWG). That's a no-fuss, no-muss approach to adding chlorine. Add salt one time to the water (occasional replenishment due to splash-out) and the system does the rest every day. No buying bleach, no pouring bleach, no recycling bleach bottles.
 
Or potentially adding a salt water chlorine generator (SWG). That's a no-fuss, no-muss approach to adding chlorine. Add salt one time to the water (occasional replenishment due to splash-out) and the system does the rest every day. No buying bleach, no pouring bleach, no recycling bleach bottles.

ndnaanvjbbm21.jpg


I will definitely look into that. Are they relatively straightforward to install? I'm pretty handy and do a lot of my own repairs (minor wiring and plumbing, carpentry, etc.).
 
They are relatively straightforward to install. I'm not your guy for the installation, but folks here can certainly guide you through that process if you do move in that direction.

Here's a good article to start your research. Salt Water Chlorine Generators - Trouble Free Pool Our SWG is on it's 7th season and I love it. Actually I LOVE it.
 
They are relatively straightforward to install. I'm not your guy for the installation, but folks here can certainly guide you through that process if you do move in that direction.

Here's a good article to start your research. Salt Water Chlorine Generators - Trouble Free Pool Our SWG is on it's 7th season and I love it. Actually I LOVE it.

After looking around I will definitely be going the SWG route. The general consensus is the CircuPool brand is recommended so I will be picking up the SJ-40 model. Will most likely wait until next season to install and thanks to everyone for all the info.

If you do go the SWCG route, part of the good news is that you'll need 70-80ppm CYA so you may not have to do much more in the way of draining and refilling. :cool:

Hah! Any excuse to not dump out 5k more gallons of water is good news to me!!
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.