Hi Vinny,
3 things:
1. Use a 10ml water sample for your FC testing. Use a rounded scoop of the DPD powder, and count each drop as 0.5ppm. This will use you kit up 2.5x slower. No need to be more accurate than 0.5.
2. Your CYA is 40. We always round up when reading that test, so your SLAM target is now 16ppm.
3. Don't chase pH or TA. Anything in the 7s is fine. With your TA as high as it is (can you double check you're using the right sample size for that? I'm surprised Cranston water is so high...), your pH will rise naturally. When it gets to 8, lower it with muriatic acid back to 7.2 and repeat until stable.