Normally, you can't put a smaller motor on a pump than the one it comes with.
However, the Tristar you have is labeled 1.85, but it's really a 1.65.
There is a full rated TriStar with 1.85 label hp and there is an uprated TriStar with a 1.65 label hp.
Both pumps are exactly the same pump. So, a 1.65 hp can be used on that pump.
In my opinion, the 1.85 is not accurate. In my opinion, the actual hp is really 1.65.
Note that if the motor has a problem, it might not be covered under warranty because it is rated less than the label from the pump.