Just opened pool, Ph > 10 and CC = 5.5

Jump to latest Follow Reply
C

ColoradoPool2022

Active member
Dec 7, 2022
25
Denver, CO
Pool Size
10880
Surface
Plaster
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
SWG Type
Pentair Intellichlor IC-20
Hello again,
We just opened our pool in CO for the 4th season and the chemicals seem to be at their worst. The company that opened our pool on Monday said the Ph was really high (not sure if/how they tested it) and put 64 oz of 20' muriatic acid in. They also put in 2 lbs of 54% cal-hypo shock. I was busy and didn't run my own tests that day (two days ago). I ran my test today and holy cow, things are a mess. I'm mostly concerned with the CC level as I tested twice and got 5.5 and 6.0. That would suggest that my break-even chlorination level is 55! That's >9 lbs of shock and that just feels like a bad idea.

My main question is- do I just drain the pool and start over? Below are my full readings as of today. For now, I'm trying to bring down the Ph and then will work on the CC based on the advice I get here. Thx for any advice!

FC- 0.5
CC- 5.5-6.0
Ph- it was purple. It took 7 drops of R015 to get to about 7.4. That suggests 70 oz of acid but I put in 50 to start and will recheck tomorrow morning. I also turned the pump up to 2,300 RPM.
TA- 130 (for some reason my TA always goes up over short periods of time. It was 80 when I closed the pool in October. Hopefully addressing the Ph situation will get me back down around 100 and I'll go from there)
CH- 370
CYA- zero. I plan to address this after the Ph and chlorine concerns. This was 60 when I closed the pool.
Salt- 3,000. I plan to address this after the Ph and chlorine concerns. This was 3,200 when I closed the pool.
Temp- 68
CSI- pool math can't calculate it given the Ph level
 
If the water is not a swamp, no need to dump.
When doing pH adjustments, do it in .4 reductions. Larger reduction calculations are not accurate. Lower .4, pump running, test 30 minutes later. Repeat until your pH is in the 7s.
Can you go test pH again now?
 
  • Like
Reactions: proavia
I don't believe the CCs. It takes FC to make CCs and they burn off rather quickly.

Have you been adding FC ?

Is the cell working yet or is it still too cold ?

Are you sure the chemicals above are all the pool guys added to the pool ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ol_whistle_britches
ColoradoPool2022 said:
The company that opened our pool on Monday said the Ph was really high (not sure if/how they tested it) and put 64 oz of 20' muriatic acid in. They also put in 2 lbs of 54% cal-hypo shock.
Click to expand...
2 lbs of 53% Cal Hypo corresponds to 13 FC in a 10k pool, if I’m running pool math correctly.

ColoradoPool2022 said:
FC- 0.5
CC- 5.5-6.0
Click to expand...
After ~ 2 days.

Newdude said:
I don't believe the CCs. It takes FC to make CCs and they burn off rather quickly.
Click to expand...
@Newdude can you please walk me through that statement? What kind of ratio would you expect to see between the FC added and having been converted to CC, and how quick should the resulting CCs burn off? Honestly looking to learn something from this. Where I live we don’t have winter, so I don’t expect to ever close a pool...
 
ol_whistle_britches said:
What kind of ratio would you expect to see between the FC added and having been converted to CC,
Click to expand...
An equilibrium between input (FC) and output (CC) as its converted. If the sun is out, you aren't going to stack CCs to get to 6, they will burn off as they accrue. Maybe it'll get to 2 CCs but not 5. If the CCs are burning through the FC that quicky, you'll have no more FC to contribute to the equation and the sun burns off the CCs a short time later (15 mins ?) and you have 0s / low for both.

Some chemicals such as MPS (non chlorine shock) or Sulfamic Acid will show as CCs.

Ammonia is another possibility but you'd have to add 10 FC and test pretty quickly to see you lost 9 of it and have 6 CCs because they haven't burned off yet.

Or its dark out and the CCs did stack.

Or testing error.

We're still working out the details. :ROFLMAO:

Deep dive:

CC - Further Reading

www.troublefreepool.com www.troublefreepool.com
 
  • Like
Reactions: ol_whistle_britches
@Newdude thanks for the response. I guess I didn’t realize the CCs could burn off that quickly. Sounds like your saying sunlight can breakdown CCs at a much higher rate than FCs, so it really shouldn’t be measurable in the timeframe mentioned. I didn’t realize you could burn >5ppm CC in a day.

PoolStored said:
I thought the same thing, but low pH is typical with Ammonia...why the high pH?
Click to expand...
I read that in the wiki and picked up on the same thought. I though the wiki may have a misprint. I thought ammonia was a somewhat basic chemical, which would lead toward a high pH, no?
 
ol_whistle_britches said:
I thought ammonia was a somewhat basic chemical, which would lead toward a high pH, no?
Click to expand...
Oxidizing ammonia creates acid by releasing hydrogen.
More than 95% of ammonia is in the form of the ammonium ion (NH4+)
2NH4+ + 3OCl- --> N2 + 3H2O + 2H+ +3Cl-
The creation of the H+ makes the pH drop.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
PoolStored said:
Oxidizing ammonia creates acid by releasing hydrogen.
More than 95% of ammonia is in the form of the ammonium ion (NH4+)
2NH4+ + 3OCl- --> N2 + 3H2O + 2H+ +3Cl-
The creation of the H+ makes the pH drop.
Click to expand...
But it doesn’t oxidize until you add the FC, right? So wouldn’t a symptom of a pool suffering an ammonia problem that has built up over time be indicated by a high pH (until you start adding FC)? I.E. if you closed the pool for months and walked away from it?

I haven’t done chemistry since college. I totally believe you.
 
ol_whistle_britches said:
But it doesn’t oxidize until you add the FC, right?
Click to expand...
HOCl and OCL- are about 50/50 at pH of 7.5.
As pH rises, HOCl decreases and OCL- increases (and the converse)
There was likely FC in the pool when they closed.
As the oxidation occurred, the OCL- (the part of the FC consumed in the oxidation of ammonia) decreases, the H+ (hydrogen ion) increases which decreases pH, the HOCl in equilibrium with OCL- is converted, and the cycle continues, which result in an increase in H+, which is a lower pH.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back
Jump to latest Follow Reply