PH, Free Cl or Total Cl digital meters? Are there any under $50 that are accurate?

pH, yes there are perfectly fine ones available. Just be sure to follow the storage instructions and calibrate regularly.

Chlorine, nope. Nothing I would consider worthwhile in the sub-$500 range, much less sub-$50.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude
To do double duty as a homebrew and pool meter I got the Apera PH60 meter, which is $80 on Amazon and has a replaceable electrode. I like it but it's more than needed for pools. Some here have gotten the Apera PH20, which is $50 and does not have a replaceable electrode. Based on my experience with the PH60 and from what I've read from others here with the PH60 and PH20, the PH20 is probably a really good meter for general pool use. There's cheaper ones, such as $15 meters, but reviews I've read on those are somewhat mixed and enough to personally push me away from buying one. They are cheap though.

Here's a pic of me testing my spa with the PH60:
full
 
  • Like
Reactions: duganderson
Curious if any of the digital meters (not the ones that use regents) are accurate for PH or Free Cl or Total Cl? Do you have any specific recommendations for accurate ones that are under $50?

Thank you, Doug
For under $50 probably not. For under $100 you’ve got a good choice of pH. It would be a no for FC, Cl or total Cl. But be aware that for a $100 pH meter you’ll need close to $100 worth’s of storage solution, cleaning solution and at least 2 calibration solutions to maintain a valid result.
 
And if you are in an area where you close your pool for a few months a pH meter does not like being idle and drying out. So you it will likely last only one season or two.
 
So then that's PH only?
Yes. Apera sells an ORP probe that works with the PH60 meter, but ORP isn't usable in a pool with CYA and other things besides FC affect the ORP reading. My understanding is ORP has some usefulness in a commercial pool with a high bather load and little to no CYA, but is checked daily or more often and re-calibrated using a FC test kit. It's not not a practical way to try and measure FC in a residential situation.

For under $50 probably not. For under $100 you’ve got a good choice of pH. It would be a no for FC, Cl or total Cl. But be aware that for a $100 pH meter you’ll need close to $100 worth’s of storage solution, cleaning solution and at least 2 calibration solutions to maintain a valid result.
Everything is more expensive outside the USA, isn't it? And I wouldn't figure you'd need cleaning solution when testing pool or spa water. But yes, even in the USA with reasonably priced Apera stuff that's probably at least $30/year in storage and calibration solutions. So even the $50 Apera PH20 meter I mentioned would run $80/year assuming a 1 year meter life, $55/year assuming a 2 year life (assuming yearly buffer/cal solution replacement).

And if you are in an area where you close your pool for a few months a pH meter does not like being idle and drying out. So you it will likely last only one season or two.
Best practice is to store the probe submerged in storage solution, which will prevent drying out and can even partially reverse the effects of drying out depending on probe type. For $15 meters like I saw your thread on reviewing this may be more hassle then it's worth, but for my $80 meter with $50 replacement probes I always rinse off then put it back in the cap filled with storage solution, where it sits until the next usage. The cap is sealed so the probe can soak with the meter in any orientation.

Still, 1-2 years even for a probe always cleaned and put in storage solution seems to be the reasonable life expectation for pH probes from what I've read. The more expensive probes just get more accuracy/faster readings over the cheaper ones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: duganderson
Everything is more expensive outside the USA, isn't it? And I wouldn't figure you'd need cleaning solution when testing pool or spa water. But yes, even in the USA with reasonably priced Apera stuff that's probably at least $30/year in storage and calibration solutions. So even the $50 Apera PH20 meter I mentioned would run $80/year assuming a 1 year meter life, $55/year assuming a 2 year life (assuming yearly buffer/cal solution replacement).

Sure is, I can get the Apera PH20 for AU$120 and the PH60 for AU$180 + postage. :( I thought cleaning when testing pool water wouldn’t be necessary either but the folks at Hanna disagreed and said the results would not be valid if the meter is not properly cleaned every 2 months.

I can get a half decent handheld meter for just over AU$100 while the required solutions from Hanna will cost me $120 + postage. I can get cheeper calibration and storage solutions off ebay but there is a confidence in quality issue to consider. I can get cheeper meters and solutions but I run the risk of the cheep meter being a random number display, great for choosing lotto numbers but not so good for pool management.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jseyfert3
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.