Bromine to chlorine, total water replacement

CZY29Z

Gold Supporter
Apr 27, 2019
1
Geneva, OH
In October 2018, I bought a house that had a 28,000 gallon inground pool. Last year was the first year I have ever tried taking care of a pool/chemicals, etc. The pool uses bromine tablets through a chemical feeder for sanitization, which was how the pool has been sanitized since construction in 2006. I am almost certain the pool water has never been totally replaced. Long story short, as a result of multiple pH bounces, very high then low bromine levels, dropping alkalinity, increased TDS, numerous pool company bills to attempt to stabilize, chemical smell of water, I have decided to completely drain the pool and start to use chlorine as described in TFP.

I called a local pool company to ask for assistance with draining, because I do not want the draining and refilling to damage the vinyl liner. The liner has one patched spot and wrinkle in the liner. I was told by this company that a total water replacementwas not necessary because the bromine would eventually get completely used up by the chlorine and when that happened, chlorine would be the only sanitizer working in the pool. I also contacted the pool builder who said the same thing and stated that a total water replacement would only be necessary if switching from chlorine to bromine, not bromine to chlorine. Both were not willing to help with the drain/refill and did not offer any suggestions to decrease the risk of damage to the liner.

I have no problems attempting this myself but want to decrease the chance of liner damage.

The goal is to be bromine free and use chlorine only. I definitely do not want to go through another Pool season like last year! Is a total water replacement necessary? Should the liner be washed or treated with anything prior to refilling? Any advice to remove the chemical feeder ? Etc, etc. The pool has a vertical grid DE 3620 filter, Hayward self-priming super pump IS-2600X5-98, Hayward H series heater H250FDN, Pentair chlorine/bromine high capacity commercial feeder HC 3315. Thanks in advance !
 

Attachments

  • 9C405A74-25F1-49DE-8466-93E6411EFA4A.jpeg
    9C405A74-25F1-49DE-8466-93E6411EFA4A.jpeg
    807.2 KB · Views: 5
  • E975959C-03CA-4FC3-BB7A-B8445EBE8442.jpeg
    E975959C-03CA-4FC3-BB7A-B8445EBE8442.jpeg
    734.8 KB · Views: 5
  • B1FBB7A0-57FF-4CE0-AD10-8C7248C18638.jpeg
    B1FBB7A0-57FF-4CE0-AD10-8C7248C18638.jpeg
    524.6 KB · Views: 4
  • 41F95333-B254-4A0C-BCB0-69FEC180A93C.jpeg
    41F95333-B254-4A0C-BCB0-69FEC180A93C.jpeg
    631.5 KB · Views: 4
  • 627DAD99-81B5-4041-80FE-2B8B1C9F70B6.jpeg
    627DAD99-81B5-4041-80FE-2B8B1C9F70B6.jpeg
    104.9 KB · Views: 5
The pool will be loaded with bromide and DMH.

A full drain and refill is the only practical solution.

However, the liner will lose its set if you drain completely unless you use a liner vacuum.

Unless the liner is in really good condition, a liner vacuum is probably not going to work.

If you want to drain and refill, you will probably have to replace the liner.

You can try the tarp method where you use a giant tarp and add water on top of the tarp while removing water from below the tarp at the same rate until the tarp goes from the top of the water to the floor.

You need to use a really big tarp.
 
They are 99.5% wrong on the bromine/chlorine chemistry. While bromine does eventually oxidize slowly to bromate, that process would take a very long time and your water would then be loaded with bromates which are considered carcinogens by the EPA.

Have you priced out a liner replacement for your pool? That would be the most straightforward but costly approach. Otherwise, you’ll have to do a series of drains and refills to get the bromide/DMH levels down. Because there’s no way to easily test for bromide and DMH, it’s pure guesswork on how many drains and refills you would need.

I also would not use the PB to do the liner replacement but find another builder in your area willing to assist you.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.