Winterization in December (Michigan) and pool cover options.

Update:

The pool froze over near the steps and the water has since gone over the skimmer port. Should I drain the water a little? I was going to remove the solar cover but it is crispy frozen. We have weather in the high 40s next week so it should free up by then. What do you think?

View attachment 620500View attachment 620501View attachment 620502

That blue floater is an anti breakage device? I'll look into pool antifreeze, going to hit up the pool store tomorrow AM.
The blue thing is a gizmo it is screwed into the skimmer hole. It is meant to keep water from entering the skimmer pipes and also to prevent the water, when frozen to not expand and crack/break the skimmer. The pool noodles add that extra layer of protection and the antifreeze helps to keep what water does get in from rain/snow melt from freezing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
Ideally since you live in a freezing area I would drain it more so you’re not draining as often. BE VERY CAREFUL about busting up the ice you could puncture the liner . The ice being disturbed could cause the ice to shift side to side or up and down???? If it was mine I’d hang loose until it melts which hopefully that’s possible before the winter sets in. Other experts will hopefully chime in on this!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
Once there’s ice on the water you should not touch it. The ice can rip your liner.
This crossed my mind AFTER I drained it and saw the ice shift. I didn't see any glaring issues and figured I'd do this now rather than when the ice becomes thicker.

Ideally since you live in a freezing area I would drain it more so you’re not draining as often.
I have a solid HPI safety cover coming soon.
 
Depends where in Michigan you are, and the usual winter precipitation. Here in the Mpls/St Paul area of Minn., the usual is to drain below the outlets, so maybe another 8-10" below what you have. Then let the winter rain/snow melt fill it up. In 30 yrs, I've never been below the skimmers come spring, and never had a risk of overflow either. Your situation may vary, as well as how permeable the cover(s) you end up using are. That solar cover is basically just heavy bubble warp, so between UV exposure from the extended use and the wear/tear from the ice, expect to have to replace it next spring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
Depends where in Michigan you are, and the usual winter precipitation. Here in the Mpls/St Paul area of Minn., the usual is to drain below the outlets, so maybe another 8-10" below what you have. Then let the winter rain/snow melt fill it up. In 30 yrs, I've never been below the skimmers come spring, and never had a risk of overflow either. Your situation may vary, as well as how permeable the cover(s) you end up using are. That solar cover is basically just heavy bubble warp, so between UV exposure from the extended use and the wear/tear from the ice, expect to have to replace it next spring.
If we get a warm enough day that the ice melts, I'll pull the solar cover out.
 
Nice temps today. I pulled the cover out and have the little giant pumping more water out. How much lower should I go? Should I go below the water jets, if so how much lower?

Pool 3 Cover Off.jpgPool 2 Cover Off.jpgPool 1 Cover Off.jpg

Can't wait till spring to pull these out.
Pool 4 Cover Off.jpg
 
I take mine about 2 “ below the rim cover on the returns. I definitely wouldn’t go any lower than that. I’m lazy and don’t want to pump out later in the winter. That puts me approximately 20” below the pool deck, loop loc covers shouldn’t be any lower then 18” below the deck. I typically get enough rain, light snow melt that fills the 2” extra before a heavy snow load on the cover. Are you leaving it without a cover? If not check what depth requirements are for your cover. Also, I’d get a pool net, leaf net whatever and try to remove the leaves carefully wo scrapping the vinyl to hard. I’d be afraid of them staining?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
I take mine about 2 “ below the rim cover on the returns. I definitely wouldn’t go any lower than that. I’m lazy and don’t want to pump out later in the winter. That puts me approximately 20” below the pool deck, loop loc covers shouldn’t be any lower then 18” below the deck. I typically get enough rain, light snow melt that fills the 2” extra before a heavy snow load on the cover. Are you leaving it without a cover? If not check what depth requirements are for your cover. Also, I’d get a pool net, leaf net whatever and try to remove the leaves carefully wo scrapping the vinyl to hard. I’d be afraid of them staining?

I have an HPI solid pool cover that I’ll be installing soon. I too am worried about scraping the liner with the hard pool rake so I think I’ll deal with the staining for now.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
I have an HPI solid pool cover that I’ll be installing soon. I too am worried about scraping the liner with the hard pool rake so I think I’ll deal with the staining for now.
I’m not familiar with a solid cover. What water level is recommended for the solid cover ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
I’m not familiar with a solid cover. What water level is recommended for the solid cover ?
Just below the returns so you can winterize easily. Try to get all the solids out from the pool bottom as they may stain if left. If you have a good leaf rake it won't damage anything.
Here’s my dilemma. HPI says 18” but I’d like to get an extra 2 to get below the returns. I am almost at 18” now. What do I do? Can I push it to 20”?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1460.jpeg
    IMG_1460.jpeg
    339.7 KB · Views: 4
  • IMG_1461.jpeg
    IMG_1461.jpeg
    508.2 KB · Views: 4
I have an HPI solid pool cover that I’ll be installing soon. I too am worried about scraping the liner with the hard pool rake so I think I’ll deal with the staining
With a solid cover you won’t get much water going in the pool to fill it up. If it’s going to be weeks before you get the cover on then yea, I’d probably go 20”. I’m sure my pool has frozen before when the return was right where yours is now with the water level. Hopefully someone else will give their opinions! Try searching the forum for what others have discussed with this topic. Good thing is you have screw in plugs so they are not going to pop out
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium
Those plugs are fine underwater. Ironically you want them more submerged because it will take a while for the ice to be thick. As said above, you wont accumulate water like those of us with mesh covers.

Draining below the returns helps with winterizing but it isn't required. Plenty just install the plug with air bubbles shooting out underwater.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helium and Diane e
I'll remove the solar cover soon, it appears to be degrading anyway. When I touched it with a pool rake, it tore very easily.

We have a fence around the pool which includes the back yard.


I would love to get a Loop Loc but the price is $1000 more than the next decent brand HPI. Some cursory research shows HPI is not a fly buy night operation. Are you familiar with HPI?

I agree with you about Vevor, looks like a generic + Amazon brand that is making it's way to Home Depot. Reviews about their covers indicate that it is a glorified thin material tarp.

I don't mind a little drilling in the winter to get this cover installed. We do occasionally get days in the 40s and 50s, which I am really hoping for now lol.


Well I sprinkled in about 4 packets worth of Clorox chlorine powder over the past 2 months. I noticed the powder sinking to the bottom of the pool and figured this contact isn't a good idea so I just waved a pool net around the bottom until it disappeared (maybe 10 seconds), I hope this didn't cause any damage.

Thanks again for the advice. I will take some photos today and upload them to show the status of the pool.
I had an HPI solid cover on my pool up north. It was on year 10 when I left, and still fine. Get the HPI, its a good cover. Also, I never drained my pool. Blow out the returns, plug them, blow out the return with gizzmo return plugs installed. NEVER an issue. No reason to drain the pool, dont waste your time
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.