Question about pipe size specified in Engineering Doc vs what the PB used

The document says to use 2. 5" pipe, so the builder should have used 2.5" pipe.

With 2" pipe, you can possibly get cavitation at full speed.
Thanks James.... yeah I dont understand why you wouldn't just follow the engineering plan that was paid for.... makes no sense to me. However, they guy that did this build also put the jets at wrong heights and installed the incorrect light niches and bubbler niche. He had to jackhammer all of the out and cement it all back together. Almost had a heart attack when I saw all the issues. Also had to cut the skimmer off the pool wall and reinstall as they didnt get gunite around most of it.
 
It's possible to cavitate the pump at higher speeds with 2" pipe.

I would have used 3" pipe.

You might have some sort of restriction in the suction.

You can check the pump display for flow and pressure at different speeds.

You might need to get a vacuum gauge and a flow meter for more detailed diagnostics.

 
It's possible to cavitate the pump at higher speeds with 2" pipe.

I would have used 3" pipe.

You might have some sort of restriction in the suction.

You can check the pump display for flow and pressure at different speeds.

You might need to get a vacuum gauge and a flow meter for more detailed diagnostics.

Thanks, I have seen it on the Screenlogic app... I have just not paid attention to it. Will check.
 
Sounds like you are getting cavitation, but it is hard to tell for sure.

See what the pump shows for flow and total system pressure at different speeds.

You might need to put the system in "service mode" to check the readings directly from the pump display as shown in the video.
 
If you are getting cavitation and you can't change the pipe, then you will have to limit the flow to below the cavitation limit.

Check the system pressure and the filter pressure at different speeds.

The system pressure minus the filter pressure will give you an estimate of the suction head loss.

Anything over 17 feet could potentially cause cavitation because it causes the net positive suction head to be below the minimum for the pump.
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
There are 4 Waterway straight body jets.

Not running at full speed (3450) I like it at about 2900... Start to see cavitation at 26-2700 or so.
With 4 jets and 100 gpm, that gives you 25 gpm per jet, which is usually max flow on a jet.

What exact model jets?

You should be able to get up to 100 gpm on the pump.

If you're getting cavitation at 100 gpm or less, then you might have a clog or other issue in the suction line.

As you can see, the pump can get beyond 100 gpm at 2,350 rpm and higher depending on the head loss from everything.

The builder should have use 2.5" as per the design specifications.

I would have used 3" for the spa suction if the flow needs to go above 90 gpm.

Can you post some videos to see if we can hear the cavitation?

1665242766205.png


 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.