TF Comparator Block vs Strips very different results: which to trust?

nopeeinool

Member
May 3, 2024
6
Rockford IL
TF-100 Comparator Block shows a ph at 6.8 or lower while HTH strip shows pH at ideal. Which can I trust and might something more be going on here?

IMG_9318.jpg
IMG_9319.jpg


Background:
We purchased a home with a 2yr old 26k gallon auto cover in ground pool end of last season last year (live in upper midwest). Pool was well maintained and I just had to manage shock and chlorine pucks (in auto chlorinator) for a few more weeks until it was professionally closed. This season I'm attempting to manage the pool entirely on my own (after professional opening) using liquid chlorine.
It had been going well, however work got busy and I didn't check or add liquid chlorine for a few days (I know - very bad). The TF-100 Comparator Block was showing very low to no chlorine and a ph level of 7.2. The water wasn't as clear anymore - could see bottom of 3ft depth but no longer at the 8ft depth. In the few days leading to today I've added liquid chlorine. The level is consistent around 2 and running the filter 24/7 is slowing clearing the water back up. However this morning I tested and noticed the pH level at 6.9. I've add 24oz of Sodium Bicarbonate and testing a few hours later and the lever seems worse (first attached photo). To rule out any issue I tried a test strip and oddly enough it shows the pH at closer to ideal (second attached photo). What could be going on here and which should I trust?
 
TF-100 Comparator Block shows a ph at 6.8 or lower while HTH strip shows pH at ideal. Which can I trust and might something more be going on here?

View attachment 574620
View attachment 574621


Background:
We purchased a home with a 2yr old 26k gallon auto cover in ground pool end of last season last year (live in upper midwest). Pool was well maintained and I just had to manage shock and chlorine pucks (in auto chlorinator) for a few more weeks until it was professionally closed. This season I'm attempting to manage the pool entirely on my own (after professional opening) using liquid chlorine.
It had been going well, however work got busy and I didn't check or add liquid chlorine for a few days (I know - very bad). The TF-100 Comparator Block was showing very low to no chlorine and a ph level of 7.2. The water wasn't as clear anymore - could see bottom of 3ft depth but no longer at the 8ft depth. In the few days leading to today I've added liquid chlorine. The level is consistent around 2 and running the filter 24/7 is slowing clearing the water back up. However this morning I tested and noticed the pH level at 6.9. I've add 24oz of Sodium Bicarbonate and testing a few hours later and the lever seems worse (first attached photo). To rule out any issue I tried a test strip and oddly enough it shows the pH at closer to ideal (second attached photo). What could be going on here and which should I trust?
You cant trust the strips. Just toss them and use the taylor kit. You should also be using the FAS-DPD chlorine test and not the yellow OTO test. The OTO test is just for quick checks of “do I have some chlorine or not”.
 
Toss the test strips in the garbage.

You should be using the comparator block for pH.

Test chlorine using the FAS/DPD drop test.

What is your TA?

Post a full set of tests with your TF-100 and record it in PoolMath
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.