Sta-Rite PLBC-178l Booster Pump Replacement Suggestions

sandyb

Active member
Apr 18, 2015
30
Granada Hills, Ca
Hello everyone,
As stated in my title, I have a circa 1999 Sta-Rite 1/2 HP Model PLBC-178L Booster pump that is getting very loud and I believe is in need of replacement. (25,000 gal in-ground pool with a Polaris 380)
I would like to get some opinions as to whether I should replace the pump like for like, or look at something more efficient.
It was suggested that I consider a Pentair LA-MS05 "Boost Rite" pump, but it is 1.1 Hp as opposed to my current 1/2 Hp...could this be a problem? also fittings are 1" compared to 3/4' on current pump.
Lastly I was looking at th Polaris PB4-60 3/4 Hp which seems to be highly rated, and matches up well, in regard to Hp and suction connection is 3/4".
I am also worried about matchup plumbing.
Any advice or suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,
Sandy