Sand Filter, Can It Be Too Big?

ksquared

Active member
Nov 22, 2014
40
Bartow FL
I've been doing much research here, appreciate all the help from duraleigh and also mas985. I've also found excellent information from ferretbone, who strongly suggested the Triton over the Tagelus, which was my first choice.

I'm now wondering, TR100 or TR140 for a pool I'm guessing at is 18K gallons. The $/filter area work out about the same, but of course the TR140 is that much more expensive. I'm not absolutely objecting to spending more money, if there is a reasonable benefit. I've noticed both have eight laterals, but the 100 has 9 1/8" where the 140 has 12". I just feel that the larger laterals are a major benefit, but yet maybe at the lower pressure running the pump for a longer time it is negated and the 9 1/8" ones work fine. I had first focused on the TR60, but that one has only six laterals at 6 11/16".

The other concern is if the TR140 would get to be too heavy for the cement pad already here. The TR140 needs a lot of sand, closing in on half a ton. I imagine the TR140 would need to be backwashed less often, but when backwashing consists of turning a valve, it doesn't seem to be a huge benefit. I also have found that possibly a pump could be OK for filtering, but not strong enough for backwashing, although I don't think that applies for my situation.

If I have to pick right now, I'm thinking the TR100, but somewhat holding off due to my non-expert status.
 
The TR100 is a great sand filter.. I convinced my friend with a pool about your size to get one and he LOVES the TR100.. It is a beast and you can go longer without backwashing.. You can also add some gravel in the bottom and then sand over it.. The nice thing with living in Florida is you get tons of water and need to backwash to get rid of water all the time.. In Oklahoma and most places I almost always recommend a cartridge filter as there is no need to backwash...

The TR140 is a HUGE filter and I think overkill for your needs, they are also more expensive because they are considered more in the commercial line of filters.. :)

 
I think the TR100 will be more than sufficient for your 18K pool. The pool I'm building (someday hopefully) will be about 34K gallons and I have the TR100. I don't know what the numbers are, but the TR100 could theoretically turnover your 18K gallons at least 6 or 7 times a day I'd imagine. More than enough capacity.
 
Great to hear, nice to know I won't be backwashing all the time!
You got a bigger pool and may have different environmental factors but I think you’ll be fine. I only backwash to drain water out when it’s too full which I’ve done once this year. I didn’t need to because of filter pressure though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TKpoolOH
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.