So I have a 3.45 HP single speed pump at a house I have purchased recently, for a roughly 35k gallon pool with attached spa. Previous owners ran it 24/7. Did the math and thats somewhere around 180ish bucks a month. Tried to set the timer to run it less, found out the timer motor is burned out and they don't sell that type of timer motor anymore. I figured rather than drop 100+ bucks on a new timer that I would just look into a new variable speed pump.
I have talked to multiple local pool places, as a certified installer is the only way to qualify for the 400 dollar power company rebate (also 100 gift card from Pentair at the moment). Unfortunately they all just want to sell me the apparently top o the line VSF model. One guy proposed a Hayward variable speed, but I have read a few negative things about Hayward so I figured I would stick with Pentair. No one I've talked to seems to realize a 3HP VS only model exists, despite me looking at it on the website on the phone with them. From what I can tell, variable flow might be nice if I had a bunch of water features, but I don't. I'm not worried about decreasing flow rates as my filter gets dirty, as I backwash my sand filter regularly anyways. I have also read a few threads on here mentioning they are not great with in floor systems, which is unfortunately what my pool came with. It would make sense to me that the constantly changing pressure as the in floor system cycles would cause the pump to be shifting RPM's constantly, which I assume would not be great.
Can someone provide a solid reason why I would want to go with the VSF model, which is what all these pool people are telling me I need, which seems to cost 400-700 more than the VS model? I realize I can just not use the variable flow setting, but it seems silly to pay for it and not use it. Should I try to talk one of these places into purchasing a regular VS model, or installing a VS that I purchase myself? Probably be a wash between the rebate and install costs at that point, but I'm not quite comfortable installing a new pump myself.
I have talked to multiple local pool places, as a certified installer is the only way to qualify for the 400 dollar power company rebate (also 100 gift card from Pentair at the moment). Unfortunately they all just want to sell me the apparently top o the line VSF model. One guy proposed a Hayward variable speed, but I have read a few negative things about Hayward so I figured I would stick with Pentair. No one I've talked to seems to realize a 3HP VS only model exists, despite me looking at it on the website on the phone with them. From what I can tell, variable flow might be nice if I had a bunch of water features, but I don't. I'm not worried about decreasing flow rates as my filter gets dirty, as I backwash my sand filter regularly anyways. I have also read a few threads on here mentioning they are not great with in floor systems, which is unfortunately what my pool came with. It would make sense to me that the constantly changing pressure as the in floor system cycles would cause the pump to be shifting RPM's constantly, which I assume would not be great.
Can someone provide a solid reason why I would want to go with the VSF model, which is what all these pool people are telling me I need, which seems to cost 400-700 more than the VS model? I realize I can just not use the variable flow setting, but it seems silly to pay for it and not use it. Should I try to talk one of these places into purchasing a regular VS model, or installing a VS that I purchase myself? Probably be a wash between the rebate and install costs at that point, but I'm not quite comfortable installing a new pump myself.