New pool - pool kit vs plaster/concrete pool

Jul 31, 2017
12
Saratoga CA
Hello,

I have some fairly basic questions about building a new pool. We currently have an old, large, kidney shaped pool in a poor location in the yard, so we are closing it. Currently debating having no pool vs. getting a small 8'X16' (Modpool like pool) or a pool kit 10'x20' (from some online store) or build one on-site. We only want a rectangular pool and not bigger than those dimensions - above vs inground doesn't matter so much. This will be in a different location in the yard, so not concerned about problems/benefits/issues that may be caused by the old pool. We are looking for a contemporary aesthetic (rectangular corners), clean straight lines etc., so some of the above ground rectangular pools (like Intex Ultra) don't quite meet that criteria.

My questions are as follows:
- seems like most above ground pool kits are oval/circular? Is that due to physics (weight of water vs. strength of the pool kit walls etc.)?
- what are the pros/cons of using a modpool/pool kit (all pool kits I found online are inground since we want a rectangle) vs building a concrete (plaster?) pool?
- isn't it easier to build an above ground pool say with 4 reinforced concrete walls than dealing with a pool kit etc.?

Other points, we are in the Bay Area (Northern CA) and this will not be a DIY project, so high labor costs are involved. I understand that an inground pool entails a new dig which will add to the cost - that cost adder aside, cost will definitely be a decision factor.

Thanks in advance.
 
Small pool like that is ideal for fiberglass. A 4ft flat bottom or little deeper is a nice plunge pool. I've seen precast septic tank makers build them and drop them on site a little smaller than that. Somewhere on the web was a company offering them premade with plaster and plumbing all ready to go. Dig a hole and set it
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.